Thursday, January 19, 2017

This is What Singapore Can Expect Now That Trump is President


  • Avatar
  • US trade that make up 28% of its GDP will be about US$5 to 6 trillion. 
  • US by adopting inflationary fiscal policies - of more Government expenditure and cut taxes --- will cause its public debt to blow up. 
  • If US restrict its trade, US fiscal deficit will further balloon. The only way for US to boost its budget to reduce its fiscal deficit and to reduce its public debt --- is to further boost its trade to form a more significant portion of its GDP. 
  • Thus Trump must be very mindful to boost trade --- not engage in trade war or restrict trade. 
  • On the hindsight, dropping TPP and TTIP is very short-sighted as these are multilateral trade deals that will bring in tremendous trade revenue back to US.
    • Avatar
    • US current public debt is $23.245 trillion. Wonder how will US finance this debt when Trump decide to cut tax further while committing higher government spendings without boosting US trade? 
    • A multilateral trade deals such as TPP will bring a mammoth trade revenue due to its Economies of Scale - as oppose to bi-lateral deal - that is negotiate one by one.
Singapore already has an FTA with US. In fact Singapore already has some sort of FTA with all TPP participating countries except Canada and Mexico. 
What would be the difference made with these 2 additional countries? 
it may make a difference but i personally don't think the difference is big enough to create a big dent or cripple our economy. 
The whole world knows the purpose of TPP is to contain China economically.

  • Avatar
  • I think a bilateral trade deal (FTA) as compared to a multilateral trade deal (such as the TPP or RCEP) - will not be as big and as beneficial. 
  • A bilateral trade deal - say between US and Singapore --- may require both Countries to have say a local content of 50% before it qualify for cut in trade tariff. Then quite a number of goods and services may not qualify for the trade tariff. 
  • For a multi-lateral trade deal say RCEP or TPP, as long as 50% of the content is make within TPP or RCEP members, then the goods and services will be qualify for trade tariff. When this happen more goods and services will qualify for cut in trade tariff - and export and import will grow exponentially compare to bilateral FTA. 
  • Thus Trump fail to recognise this fact - and miss a whole huge opportunity in big jump in trade.
    • Avatar
    • Trump say he prefer bilateral trade deal as compare to multilateral trade deal - will miss the Economies of Scale in trade - as many goods and services may not meet the local content criteria - and fall out of the trade deal. 
    • For eg. a company may buy raw material from Country A, semi-make product in Country B and assemble in Singapore. 
    • As the local content is only 20%, it will not qualify for the cut in trade tariff under the FTA. 

    • In a multilateral trade deal, Country A and/or Country B maybe a TPP members. 
    • Thus the local content (including TPP member Country) - will make up at least 50% - and thus qualify for the cut in trade tariff - and this will boost more trade. 
    • Thus Trump fail to see this benefit.
      • Avatar
      • Trump without understanding the detail and benefits --- often resort to tweets to dismiss it - and miss the big picture and big benefits. 

      • And later realise China led RCEP and FTAPP will blaze ahead with all of US trading partners --- leaving US to catch its tail.
        • Whether be it RCEP or FTAs, first and foremost, in order to survive, we must maintain good relationship with our very important trade partners. From the chart above, China ranked top, I think we better learn to be smart and not to provoke China to anger in any unnecessary aspect.
            • Avatar
            • ricky l ricky l 18 seconds ago Singapore, China to hold Joint Council for Bilateral Cooperation meeting next month Posted 17 Jan 2017 20:30 Updated 17 Jan 2017 21:24 Singapore's Permanent Secretary for Foreign Affairs Chee Wee Kiong (left) with China's Vice Foreign Minister Liu Zhenmin on Jan 17, 2017. (Photo: MFA) SINGAPORE: China's Vice Foreign Minister Liu Zhenmin met Singapore's Permanent Secretary for Foreign Affairs Chee Wee Kiong in Singapore on Tuesday (Jan 17) and discussed upcoming bilateral exchanges such as the Joint Council for Bilateral Cooperation to be held next month, and the China-Singapore Forum on Leadership later this year. According to a post on the website of Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA), the two co-chaired the 10th Bilateral Consultations between the Singapore and Chinese foreign ministries. During their meeting, Mr Chee and Mr Liu "reviewed the longstanding and multi-faceted cooperation between Singapore and China". MFA added the two sides noted that their high-level exchanges were maintained in 2016, including Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong's meetings with Chinese President Xi Jinping at the G20 Summit in Hangzhou and with Premier Li Keqiang at the ASEAN Summit in Vientiane. Mr Chee Wee Kiong and Mr Liu Zhenmin tossing a prosperity salad or yusheng during lunch on Tuesday (Jan 17). (Photo: MFA) Mr Liu and Mr Chee reviewed the good progress of the two sides' government-to-government projects, including the latest Chongqing Connectivity Initiative, MFA said. Mr Chee also expressed Singapore's support for China's "One Belt, One Road" initiative - a new area of collaboration which would further build upon Singapore and China's substantive bilateral ties, MFA added. Both sides also discussed strengthening ASEAN-China relations and connectivity, "including synergies between the Master Plan for ASEAN Connectivity 2025 and the 'Belt and Road' initiative". They also requested that the Singapore Tourism Board and China National Tourist Administration "collaborate and discuss concrete plans to promote tourism between ASEAN and China", as part of the ASEAN-China Year of Tourism Cooperation in 2017. - CNA/hs
              • Avatar
              • Singaporeans must understand that ASEAN form the core of our interest - as Singapore is situated right at the heart of ASEAN in a multi-racial and multi-cultural Nation State. 
              • Singapore play an important role of "connecting" ASEAN to China ---- to support China's One Belt One Road initiatives as well as the larger RCEP and FTAPP trade initiative. 
              • When some ASEAN members have some friction with China - specifically maritime disputes on some islands ----- Singapore need to articulate a peaceful initiatives to resolve dispute - that is seen to be fair and just - to help disputing Countries to resolve their dispute fairly and peacefully --- so that Asia Pacific region will not see military conflict and confrontation. 
              • Only upon winning the trusts of both ASEAN and China ---- can Singapore help to successfully play the important role of "connecting" ASEAN to China ---- to support China's One Belt One Road initiatives as well as the larger RCEP and FTAPP trade initiative.
                • Avatar
                • If Singapore did not do things right ---- in the context of ASEAN interest vis-a-vis China's interest ----- Singapore will not be seen as an honest broker ------- and will fail in successfully connecting ASEAN to China ---- to secure a "Win-Win outcome". 

                • Now both ASEAN and China ---- see the critical role that Singapore has played and China is patching up with Singapore - while the maritime disputes has more or less quiet down.
                  • Avatar
                  • And the TPP is similar to this ASEAN-China connectivity. 
                  • The original idea is to secure and ratify the TPP. Upon ratification, Singapore will play the "connectivity role" to connect US-led TPP to China-led RCEP and FTAPP -------- that is "US-China" trade deal connectivity. 
                  • By doing so, there will be less opportunity for US to fight China and vice versa. 
                  • Trump squandered it all. 
                  • Conversely, ASEAN members that have dispute with China - will also have less chance to resort to military conflict in South China Sea --- due to the RCEP initiatives - as Economic deal is at stake. 
                  • Conversely, Japan and S Korea will have less likely to resort to military conflict with China on East China Sea --- due to the RCEP initiatives - as Economic deal is at stake. 
                  • Note :- TPP and RCEP is not just about Economic deal ----- it is also Security deal - to prevent big war from erupting. 
                  • Trump fail to see this.
                    • Avatar
                    • Trump only see the 5 cents, 10 cents things. 

                    • Trump fail to see the "strategic vision" and the "big picture".
                      • Avatar
                      • President Obama started TPP to "contain" and as a pivot to China. 

                      • Singapore intend to turn it around and attempt to connect TPP to RCEP via FTAPP - so that US and China can connect Economically --- and this will prevent Big War from erupting.

                      • US know this. 
                      • China know this. 

                      • But Trump don't know this.
                        • Avatar
                        • The moment Trump halt trade, drop TPP and start trade war, ----- the chances of Trump ratcheting with his naval fleet to sabre-rattling with China naval fleet --- become higher and higher in the Asia Pacific region. 
                        • The A2/AD scenario --- will arise and erupt. 
                        • Btw, A2 / AD - means Anti-Access, Aerial Denial battle scenario will arise.
                          • Avatar
                          • Thus even during the US election ----- already say Trump may "unintentionally" trigger a WW3. 

                          • The intuition is not wrong ---- unless Trump or his team suddenly "gain Enlightenment" --- see the "light" -- "the Light of Wisdom" ---- to prevent mishaps from happening.
                            • Avatar
                            • Otherwise - you think why China suddenly "gardan garbo" - to seize our Terrex ---- as it has reached an "emergency situation".
                              • Avatar
                              • Very well said @ricky. Trump is stupid and will bring the downfall of US.......lol!
                                • Avatar
                                • It is not easy to be a little "red dot" to play a peacemaker for the greater good - risking to get "rap" by the SuperPowers. 
                                • For The greater good of ASEAN - where we are at the core of ASEAN.
                                • For The greater good of Asia Pacific region - where we need to balancing the rising power of China plus the interest of other major Asian powers. 
                                • For The greater good of the World - where US and China is challenging one another to be the SuperPowers of World Leadership.
                                  • Avatar
                                  • Any mishandling will mean devastating Big War in the Asia Pacific region --- where we are at the Heart of ASEAN, 
                                  • Heart of Asia Pacific region, 
                                  • Heart of the World.
                                    • Avatar
                                    • hey ricky. china is manipulating everything from head to toe, and building missles on island, are you awake? Or are you gona wait till 20 years later and pay the price? You are the one shortsighted and only care for youself.
                                      • Avatar
                                      • @Pierce the heart What does Economic deal and trade deal got to do with the maritime dispute? Just because of one small issue, you totally rule out a trading partner?
                                        • Avatar
                                        • @Pierce the heart - Moreover Singapore is not part of the claimant of the maritime dispute. 
                                        • So why aren't we going to work with China on the Economic deal?
                                        •  In addition, claimants of South China Sea - such as Malaysia, Philippines - even Brunei and Vietnam are willing to work with China on the Economic deal under the ASEAN community with RCEP --- and not let a small issue - maritime spat derail the entire Trade deal --- bearing in mind the global protectionism rearing its head. 
                                        • Even Japan who has spat with China on some islands in East China Sea - also indicate that she want to work more closely with China on the RCEP. So what is the fuss?
                                          • Avatar
                                          • @Pierce the heart - alternatively, you can hug the islands, drink sea water and fish for your food - without the need for trade and business. 
                                          • At the same time, baring your chest while the China naval ship shoot water canon at you. 
                                          • Or you can work with China with dialogue, consultation, negotiation to strike a win-win deal - Economic deal in conjunction with the island deal as one sweeten package to resolve the maritime dispute once and for all. 
                                          • You must note that not only China place missile on the islands. 
                                          • Other claimants also has placed missile, troops or ships on the islands they have landed, albeit China did it on a larger scale.
                                          •  It is up to the claimants countries to work out something with China to resolve the island dispute while observing the rule of law.
                                            • Avatar
                                            • @Pierce the heart - or you can opt for what happen in Aleppo --- let US and Russia bomb the place and destroy all infrastructure in your islands and your homeland --- leaving all the infrastructure in ruin and all your people killed ---- but no money to build the infrastructure. 
                                            • Then you can have the island all by yourself because your ashes is mixed very well with all the rubbles and bomblets in the island.
                                              • Avatar
                                              • And now Russia win the war, but is there anyone giving Syria money to build their infrastructure? 
                                              • Did US give money to Syria to rebuild the infrastructure? 
                                              • Did Arab coalition give money to Syria to rebuild the infrastructure? 
                                              • Did Russia and Iran give money to Syria to rebuild the infrastructure? 
                                              • No right? 
                                              • So now Assad reclaim Aleppo - but the whole country in a ruin, infrastructure all destroyed and damage. 
                                              • So where do the Syrian people live? 
                                              • In desert, in tent under hot sun - no water, no food. 
                                              • So Pierce at heart --- do you want to be like Aleppo?
                                              • Yah, easy to talk, easy to be foolhardy. 
                                              • But when the bomb start raining at your head --- I think you concussion - and Enlightenment come - but too late --- as your Enlightenment will follow by your demise. Think first before you talk big, think foolhardy.
                                                • Avatar
                                                • At least your President Dutre is smarter than you. 
                                                • He can think before he act - though he like to fire off through his mouth first.
                                                  • Avatar
                                                  • Just let me tell you something, no Asia Pacific members want a war in Asia Pacific. 
                                                  • All want peace and all want to resolve disputes through negotiation, consultation, dialogue --- though there are also military posturing. 
                                                  • The only way to sweeten the disputes and let the disputes resolve via peaceful means - will be through Economic deal. 
                                                  • Don't provoke war, military conflict unnecessarily. 
                                                  • No one is going to win in war --- as it only means destruction, death, casualties. 
                                                  • What happen in Middle East and Ukraine - we should not attempt to replicate in Asia Pacific.

No comments:

Post a Comment