====
After note:-
Source:- Google Gemini AI
Singapore does attempt to take legal action against companies responsible for regional smoke, but faces major practical and diplomatic barriers.
The Law Exists
Singapore passed the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act (THPA) to punish any company—local or foreign—that causes or contributes to unhealthy haze in Singapore, with daily fines up to $100,000.
Singapore authorities have served notices and sought company data or directors for questioning under this law.
The Straits Times
Why Prosecution is Difficult
Sovereignty and Political Friction: Indonesia has pushed back against Singapore enforcing laws over acts done on Indonesian soil, arguing that it infringes on national sovereignty and that matters should be handled via Indonesian courts or regional pacts.
Lack of Local Data and Cooperation:
Singapore needs concrete evidence like land ownership maps and concession data, which Indonesian authorities have sometimes been slow or reluctant to share.
The Business Times
Jurisdiction and Enforcement: For Singapore courts to prosecute, the target company or its representatives must have a legal presence in Singapore or comply with court summons. Many overseas managers or directors simply do not show up, making arrests or court orders hard to execute outside Singapore.
The Law Exists
Singapore passed the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act (THPA) to punish any company—local or foreign—that causes or contributes to unhealthy haze in Singapore, with daily fines up to $100,000.
Singapore authorities have served notices and sought company data or directors for questioning under this law.
The Straits Times
Why Prosecution is Difficult
Sovereignty and Political Friction: Indonesia has pushed back against Singapore enforcing laws over acts done on Indonesian soil, arguing that it infringes on national sovereignty and that matters should be handled via Indonesian courts or regional pacts.
Lack of Local Data and Cooperation:
Singapore needs concrete evidence like land ownership maps and concession data, which Indonesian authorities have sometimes been slow or reluctant to share.
The Business Times
Jurisdiction and Enforcement: For Singapore courts to prosecute, the target company or its representatives must have a legal presence in Singapore or comply with court summons. Many overseas managers or directors simply do not show up, making arrests or court orders hard to execute outside Singapore.
----
Prompt :- Did singapore successfully prosecute any companies that cause haze in Indonesia?
Google Gemini AI response:-
No, Singapore has not successfully prosecuted or convicted any foreign companies under its anti-haze law.
Enforcement Actions Under the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act (THPA)
Passed in 2014: Singapore enacted the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act to penalize entities inside or outside Singapore whose conduct causes or contributes to unhealthy haze pollution in the country.
2015/2016 Investigations: Following severe regional fires in 2015, Singapore's National Environment Agency (NEA) served preventive notices and information requests to several Indonesian pulp and paper suppliers, including units of Asia Pulp and Paper (APP).
Stalls and Warrants: Singapore issued a detention/court warrant for an uncooperative Indonesian company director in 2016, but met strong pushback from the Indonesian government, which argued that Singapore's extraterritorial enforcement infringed on Indonesian legal sovereignty.
Cases Closed or Unresolved: NEA eventually cleared two of the firms after accepting explanations regarding their lack of association with the land, while remaining investigations stalled due to lack of cooperation from overseas corporate respondents and jurisdictional friction.
Google Gemini AI response:-
No, Singapore has not successfully prosecuted or convicted any foreign companies under its anti-haze law.
Enforcement Actions Under the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act (THPA)
Passed in 2014: Singapore enacted the Transboundary Haze Pollution Act to penalize entities inside or outside Singapore whose conduct causes or contributes to unhealthy haze pollution in the country.
2015/2016 Investigations: Following severe regional fires in 2015, Singapore's National Environment Agency (NEA) served preventive notices and information requests to several Indonesian pulp and paper suppliers, including units of Asia Pulp and Paper (APP).
Stalls and Warrants: Singapore issued a detention/court warrant for an uncooperative Indonesian company director in 2016, but met strong pushback from the Indonesian government, which argued that Singapore's extraterritorial enforcement infringed on Indonesian legal sovereignty.
Cases Closed or Unresolved: NEA eventually cleared two of the firms after accepting explanations regarding their lack of association with the land, while remaining investigations stalled due to lack of cooperation from overseas corporate respondents and jurisdictional friction.
====
If we do what that environmentalist activist say to prosecute companies in Indonesia - we will enter into a political firestorm with Indonesia.
Malaysia is very badly affected 300 - 500 psi points but yet did not take drastic measures as what the environmentalist activist suggested.
Why do we want to put ourselves in a confrontational role with Indonesia over an occasional over 100 psi points?
That is why I say this chap cannot see the big picture.
Only singlemindedly focus on his pet topic "environment, environment.... " And nothing else.
Very hard to talk to such uncompromising hardcore absolute activists to resolve national issues that needs to balance many conflicting national needs.
Because he thought the whole world can only revolve around his environment viewpoint and nothing else even when presented with relevant indisputable facts to his contrary.
And this activist quickly concluded and make false accusation that our Government compromise (in his word - "close one eye") because we are profit focus and refuse to prosecute.
This is fringe on innuendo that our Government is "corrupt" - which make me furious especially when this statement is made in a public forum.
Such stance will elicit very strong pushback from the mainstream people who are pro-development but mindful of the need to protect the environment that backfire on the environmentalist ideals in which they seek to achieve.
On the hindsight, there are few PAP moderate environmentalists MPs who are able to accept development and work for Win-Win solutions through give-and-take.
They will have a higher chances of success to work with the mainstream pro-development people who are also mindful of the protection of the environment.
Hardcore radical uncompromising environmentalists however will spoil the whole show and trigger unnecessary pushback because they don't understand the philosophy of Middle Path.
That's why absolute uncompromising environmentalist activist very scary.
They are absolutely anti-development and not driven by fact-based circumstances.
Society cannot progress.
----
Google Gemini AI describe:-
A person who holds absolute, uncompromising, or extremist environmentalist viewpoints can be described by several specific terms depending on the exact nature of their philosophy and actions:
Core Terms & Classifications
Core Terms & Classifications
1. Radical Environmentalist
2. Eco-extremist
3. Deep Ecologist
4. Eco-terrorist / Ecotage Practitioner
====
After note:-
Why new BTO flats have no void deck?
Source:- Google Gemini AI
New Build-To-Order (BTO) flats have smaller, more restricted, and "maze-like" void decks because HDB has shifted its design priorities toward unit privacy, higher density, and alternative communal spaces. Reddit·r/singapore +4
While traditional void decks were wide, open, and linear, modern blocks feature structural trade-offs:
Better Privacy and Ventilation: Newer blocks are designed with non-linear stacks so that bedroom and living room windows face outward instead of directly onto common corridors, eliminating corridor-facing windows that compromise privacy. Reddit +2
Structural Pillar Alignment: The load-bearing walls and pillars required to support these complex, privacy-optimized upper-floor layouts extend straight down to the ground floor, creating segmented, maze-like ground layouts. Reddit·r/singapore +1
Shift to Decentralized Spaces: HDB now distributes community areas across alternative spaces like roof gardens, sky terraces, precinct pavilions, and fitness corners rather than concentrating all social activity at the ground floor. Mothership +1
Managing Social and Noise Issues: More partitioned layouts and perimeter barriers help prevent large-scale rowdy activities, loitering, or unauthorized ball games that historically caused noise complaints in older, wide-open void decks.
While traditional void decks were wide, open, and linear, modern blocks feature structural trade-offs:
Better Privacy and Ventilation: Newer blocks are designed with non-linear stacks so that bedroom and living room windows face outward instead of directly onto common corridors, eliminating corridor-facing windows that compromise privacy. Reddit +2
Structural Pillar Alignment: The load-bearing walls and pillars required to support these complex, privacy-optimized upper-floor layouts extend straight down to the ground floor, creating segmented, maze-like ground layouts. Reddit·r/singapore +1
Shift to Decentralized Spaces: HDB now distributes community areas across alternative spaces like roof gardens, sky terraces, precinct pavilions, and fitness corners rather than concentrating all social activity at the ground floor. Mothership +1
Managing Social and Noise Issues: More partitioned layouts and perimeter barriers help prevent large-scale rowdy activities, loitering, or unauthorized ball games that historically caused noise complaints in older, wide-open void decks.
====
After note:-
Why new BTO flats have no rubbish chute per unit but use centralised chute?
Source:- Google Gemini AI
New HDB BTO flats use centralised rubbish chutes instead of in-unit chutes to reduce pests, bad smells, and health risks inside homes.
Pest and Odour Control: In-unit chutes in the kitchen let cockroaches, rats, and foul smells enter the flat if the rubber seals wore out or weren't closed tightly.
Hygiene and Cleanliness: Dropping trash straight from the kitchen into a shared shaft often led to waste sticking to the sides of the pipes, causing sanitary issues inside private living spaces.
Easier Maintenance: Centralised or common landing chutes keep waste disposal outside the apartment, making it easier for town council cleaners to collect trash and maintain the estate.
Space for Recycling: Centralised areas on each floor now feature side-by-side dual systems, including designated recycling chutes to support national green goals. CNA
====
After note:-
Why not all BTO flats entrance doors are fire-rated?
Source:- Google Gemini AI
LCL Danny 心 (1st HP):
Yes, new HDB Build-To-Order (BTO) flats use fire-rated doors for their main entrance if the unit is located along a designated fire escape route.
When BTO Entrance Doors Must Be Fire-Rated
Near escape routes: Flats with main entrances positioned within 3 meters of an exit staircase, lift lobby, or designated fire escape path are fitted with a 30-minute (half-hour) fire-rated door and frame by HDB.
Open external corridors: If a BTO unit's entrance faces an open external corridor and sits further than 3 meters away from an exit staircase or lift lobby, HDB may install a standard non-fire-rated wooden main door. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Key Features of BTO Fire-Rated Doors
Self-closing mechanism: Fire-rated entrance doors come equipped with an approved door closer to ensure the door automatically shuts tight during an emergency to block fire and smoke.
Yes, new HDB Build-To-Order (BTO) flats use fire-rated doors for their main entrance if the unit is located along a designated fire escape route.
When BTO Entrance Doors Must Be Fire-Rated
Near escape routes: Flats with main entrances positioned within 3 meters of an exit staircase, lift lobby, or designated fire escape path are fitted with a 30-minute (half-hour) fire-rated door and frame by HDB.
Open external corridors: If a BTO unit's entrance faces an open external corridor and sits further than 3 meters away from an exit staircase or lift lobby, HDB may install a standard non-fire-rated wooden main door. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Key Features of BTO Fire-Rated Doors
Self-closing mechanism: Fire-rated entrance doors come equipped with an approved door closer to ensure the door automatically shuts tight during an emergency to block fire and smoke.
Compliance labels: They feature an official accredited labeller's tag or sticker. HDB
Replacement rules: If you decide to replace your BTO main entrance door later on, you must use a certified half-hour fire-rated door and keep the self-closing device functional if your unit originally required one. The Straits Times
----
Not all entrance doors in new HDB BTO flats are fire-rated because the Fire Code only requires them when a unit is located near a critical escape route. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Where Fire-Rated Doors Are Required
Within 3 metres of an exit: Units located within 3.0 metres of a lift lobby, fire lift, or staircase exit must have a certified fire-rated door (typically half-hour or FD30-rated).
Containing high-risk areas: This prevents fire and smoke from quickly compromising primary escape paths during an emergency. HDB
Why Units on External Corridors Differ
Open-air ventilation: Units that face an external, open-air corridor and sit further than 3 metres from a staircase do not need a fire-rated entrance door.
Natural heat dispersion: External corridors naturally disperse heat and smoke efficiently, reducing the risk of fire jumping across units. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Overall compartment design: Every HDB flat is already built as an independent fire compartment using thick concrete walls and floors to contain internal fires. Ministry of National Development (MND) +1
Financial prudence: Omitting unnecessary fire-rated doors where external ventilation provides sufficient safety balances regulatory compliance with building costs. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Not all entrance doors in new HDB BTO flats are fire-rated because the Fire Code only requires them when a unit is located near a critical escape route. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Where Fire-Rated Doors Are Required
Within 3 metres of an exit: Units located within 3.0 metres of a lift lobby, fire lift, or staircase exit must have a certified fire-rated door (typically half-hour or FD30-rated).
Containing high-risk areas: This prevents fire and smoke from quickly compromising primary escape paths during an emergency. HDB
Why Units on External Corridors Differ
Open-air ventilation: Units that face an external, open-air corridor and sit further than 3 metres from a staircase do not need a fire-rated entrance door.
Natural heat dispersion: External corridors naturally disperse heat and smoke efficiently, reducing the risk of fire jumping across units. Ministry of National Development (MND)
Overall compartment design: Every HDB flat is already built as an independent fire compartment using thick concrete walls and floors to contain internal fires. Ministry of National Development (MND) +1
Financial prudence: Omitting unnecessary fire-rated doors where external ventilation provides sufficient safety balances regulatory compliance with building costs. Ministry of National Development (MND)
====
No comments:
Post a Comment