Wednesday, April 7, 2021

REACH 213 - How life have changed since covid (SK)

07 Apr 2021 (11am - 7pm)

 

REACH

[10:55 am, 07/04/2021] +REACH: Dear contributors,

Welcome back! ��

⏰ We will be opening the chat from 11am to 7pm today. ⏰

House Rules (short version of our Terms of Use) to keep in mind:

1. Be kind and respectful. We all want to be in a safe space to share our views.

2. Any and all threatening, abusive, vulgar or racially, religiously and ethnically objectionable content is prohibited.

3. Consider the quiet ones among us and give them a chance to comment.

4. No need to repeat your comment or in different forms (including caps) - we heard you loud and clear the first time.

5. Let’s protect each other’s privacy and keep contact details in this group what it should always be - confidential.

Full set of Terms of Use: https://go.gov.sg/reach-whatsapp-terms

We will strive to uphold these rules to ensure this is a safe space for all.

Please be assured that the points made by participants during the chat are aggregated and shared with relevant agencies.

The topic will be posted shortly.

Thank you

Megan ��

[11:13 am, 07/04/2021] +REACH: �� Topic ��

Last year on 7 April, Singapore went into Circuit Breaker mode, marking the start of safe distancing measures across all our common spaces. Today, 75% of the workforce can return to workplaces.

�� How has life changed for you in the past year? Have your perspectives about Singapore and being Singaporean changed? How?

Please feel free to share with us your stories and personal experiences!����

On April 7 2020, Singapore went indoors. Amid a spike in Covid-19 cases, schools and workplaces were ordered closed. For the next two months, the country stayed home except for getting food and exercise. The country emerged again, on June 1, with restrictions in place and work-from-home being the default.

A lot has changed since then, with Singapore cautiously moving into Phase 3 and recently allowing 75% of workers to return back to office, increasing capacities for solemnisations and other events, and accelerating the vaccination roll-out programme to allow those aged 45 to 59 years old to get vaccinated.

�� Then and now multimedia by ST: https://www.straitstimes.com/multimedia/then-and-now-the-difference-a-year-makes-as-spore-cautiously-reopens-post-circuit-breaker

�� Stories by fellow Singaporeans : https://www.straitstimes.com/multimedia/graphics/2021/04/circuit-breaker-1-year-on/index.html?shell

�� https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/covid-19-jabs-to-be-extended-to-those-below-45-from-june

�� https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/one-year-after-circuit-breaker-people-in-spore-socialising-less-working-more-mental

------

 

[11:14 am, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Excuse me going off topic and this isn't intended to be political, but I think it's wrong someone can commit a crime and then when fined they can raise money from 2,000 people to pay it off. This makes a mockery of our justice system.

[11:15 am, 07/04/2021] +Ben: It also suggests you are above the law if a small number of people can circumvent the punishment. So can people now defame others if they have wealthy backers behind them?

[11:17 am, 07/04/2021] +KS Foong: Fully agree

 

[11:21 am, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Better to get ourselves vaccinated ASAP.

A bad news about covid.

 

[11:21 am, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1 in 3 COVID-19 survivors suffer mental, neurological problems: Study

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/world/1-in-3-covid-19-survivors-mental-neurological-problems-14571084

 

[11:27 am, 07/04/2021] +YT: He could do that because the "punishment" was too little, too lenient. If the amount was higher, then crowd funding would be more difficult. With this kind of leniency and the ease that the damages was paid, more will be emboldened to slander and tell untruths because they know they can get away with just a slap in the wrist. What's the world coming to?

[11:30 am, 07/04/2021] +YT: Looking back, I wondered how those few weeks went by. The fact of the matter was, and still is, the decision was a tough one but it saved lives and saved Singapore from a second wave. Frankly, for me, life is pretty much the same before, during and after circuit breaker. The difference is in the added precautions and enhanced awareness of personal hygiene. Many feel restricted. But I don't. In fact, I quite enjoy the quiet months although I know that's not sustainable as many people have lost their livelihoods and the country took a big hit in terms of revenue from visitors, trade etc.,

[11:33 am, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Well, $100,000 is a lot of money in normal circumstances, but if 2,000 people who want to buck the system for $50 each then it's not just meaningless but almost contempt of court. I'm not in favour of stamping down on honest challenge and debate but this was clearly an attempt to undermine the credibility of Singapore's PM and there was no apology given after. That's bad for every Singaporean and should be treated as such.

[11:36 am, 07/04/2021] +KS Foong: Agree. This is a loophole! How to control this type of cloud fund raising?

[11:40 am, 07/04/2021] +Ben: I have a lot of respect for how Singapore and Singaporeans responded to the situation. The big picture and sense of community were taken seriously and we didn't see the problems of other countries such as mask resistance and protests. Our response showed we can work together and have the discipline needed. There are strange anomalies of course, which don't seem fair, but no system is perfect and compromises have to be made. I actually like the social distancing, with people not pushing into me at a queues and generally more space. Maybe some of the social awareness can teach us some good lessons and it would be good to take stock of what we have learnt as a nation and carry forward the good thinking.

 

[11:51 am, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

CNA reported that below 45 years old can register for vaccination.

But what are the age limit?

That's can children up to 16 years old vaccinate?

 

[11:57 am, 07/04/2021] +En: Think still age 16 and above

[11:59 am, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Status quo only 16 and up can take

 

[0:05 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

I also thought so.

But CNA news did not explicitly say so.

Children trial below 16 ongoing. Some countries deciding to roll out to children.

 

[0:12 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

I don't think we can stop anyone to source fund to pay their fines.

Be it from their savings, business, income, friends or strangers.

The only consolation is, he is charged in court, found guilty and he got a "black record".

 

[0:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Kids are stronger than we think actually but we prefer to err on the side of caution

[0:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Let them do studies and finalize then we follow bah

 

[0:19 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

MOH got to decide and make assessment.

 

[0:20 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: I agree with this

[0:21 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: If the majority thinks he’s sprouting nonsense and he still doesn’t learn just ignore

[0:21 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: There will always be a small base for or against anything one

[0:21 pm, 07/04/2021] +REACH: Unemployment rates in Singapore decline for fourth straight month in February

Singapore's employment situation has continued to improve, with declines seen across the overall, resident and citizen unemployment rates, said Manpower Minister Josephine Teo.

More: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/jobs/unemployment-rates-in-singapore-decline-for-fourth-straight-month-in-february

[0:40 pm, 07/04/2021] +En: What’s today’s topic again?

[0:44 pm, 07/04/2021] +Bobby Tan: �� Topic ��

Last year on 7 April, Singapore went into Circuit Breaker mode, marking the start of safe distancing measures across all our common spaces. Today, 75% of the workforce can return to workplaces.

�� How has life changed for you in the past year? Have your perspectives about Singapore and being Singaporean changed? How?

Please feel free to share with us your stories and personal experiences!����

On April 7 2020, Singapore went indoors. Amid a spike in Covid-19 cases, schools and workplaces were ordered closed. For the next two months, the country stayed home except for getting food and exercise. The country emerged again, on June 1, with restrictions in place and work-from-home being the default.

A lot has changed since then, with Singapore cautiously moving into Phase 3 and recently allowing 75% of workers to return back to office, increasing capacities for solemnisations and other events, and accelerating the vaccination roll-out programme to allow those aged 45 to 59 years old to get vaccinated.

�� Then and now multimedia by ST: https://www.straitstimes.com/multimedia/then-and-now-the-difference-a-year-makes-as-spore-cautiously-reopens-post-circuit-breaker

�� Stories by fellow Singaporeans : https://www.straitstimes.com/multimedia/graphics/2021/04/circuit-breaker-1-year-on/index.html?shell

�� https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/covid-19-jabs-to-be-extended-to-those-below-45-from-june

�� https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/one-year-after-circuit-breaker-people-in-spore-socialising-less-working-more-mental

[0:51 pm, 07/04/2021] +En: Thank you ����

[0:55 pm, 07/04/2021] +En: Heartwarming to see people helping each other and all during difficult times ��

[1:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +En: Wfh has become a norm for me over the past year, find it a bit challenging to adjust back now �� but I think the wfh and other measures really helped SG get to our current stage where we can reopen further.

Wondering what you guys think about how SG handled COVID in the past year? ��

[1:05 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ana: I love wfh. Gives me a couple hours of extra sleep and family time on the go. I'm much more willing to put in extra hours since I don't have to factor in travel time and spending dedicated family time

[1:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: I'm happy with the increased space overall as people stayed home, but that space is eroding again.

[1:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ana: Yes, especially on public transport and on the roads :(

[1:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: +1

[1:09 pm, 07/04/2021] +Dan: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/one-year-after-circuit-breaker-people-in-spore-socialising-less-working-more-mental

[1:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes, me too. The option to go in is also good,  but pressing people to do now isn't,  especially when vaccines for under 59 have only just started.

[1:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: This is a relevant point as well.  We are losing social interaction, and some people are feeling isolated.

[1:19 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: And in lifts...

[1:34 pm, 07/04/2021] +Bobby Tan: I still prefer WFH as I need to avoid crowded places and not too many ppl. I do accounts so I can really WFH as the accounting software is in cloud.

[1:36 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ana: Exactly! Just because COVID is handled well doesn't mean it isn't a threat that I'm not vaccinated against

[1:43 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: The problem is that we are too comfortable with WFH, and when require the staff to come in for a period of time in the office for a week faces a huge pushback. This is for social interaction in office with colleagues and some work cannot be done from home. The expected volume increase as more company coming back on to office. There is so much of push back

[1:45 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: but then the question is whether the benefit of social interaction in the office outweighs the risk of picking up a bug from dunno where and bringing it back home to our loved ones lah

[1:45 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: for some WFH is an excuse for extended holiday. During the WFH period, we caught some staffs went shopping or doing some recreation .... so ???

[1:46 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: This type of behaviour make bosses doubt WFH concept

[1:47 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: Our productivity drops and I feel it in the Civil service responses

[1:51 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: it depends on the nature of work involved, but my question is "when you're employed, does the company buy your time or does the company buy your work product?" because if it's the latter, it shouldn't make a difference when and where i do the work done within reasonable turnaround time. the difference comes when you say the company is paying for my time, and between 9 to 6, my time belongs to the company and no one else.

 

[1:52 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1. This covid pandemic is a global threat that has threaten human lives worldwide, in a mammoth proportion - and greatly impacted the Global Economy resulted in business loss and job loss. The GDP worldwide fall in negative territory and cause many Government to either dig into reserves or borrow in big amount to keep business and jobs afloat.

 

2. This covid pandemic has also changed how global humanity live, work, doing business, socialise, play and travel. For humanity are in a "psuedo-slavery" to the covid - as humans have to wear masks, maintain social distancing, unable to fly or travel overseas with ease etc. This is an unnatural consequence as a result of the pandemic.

 

3. There are some positive outcome though among all the negative impact :-

a. Singapore business are forced to transform instantly to survive - by going digital (in which ITM has encouraged) - but catalyse by the pandemic - as people interaction is reduced to the minimum. This will make our Economy, Business and our Workers more competitive in the long run.

b. More business and people adopt hybrid work and study arrangement - where people can work from home remotely, travel to work when required to --- and thus facilitate more balance family-and-work life.

 

4. But the negative impact are abundant :-

a. Social interaction among people drastically drop.

b. WFH has also resulted in more domestic violence.

c. Few industry sectors negatively impacted like air travel, sea cruise, tourism, f&b, hotel hospitality etc.

d. Government need to dig into reserves to support business and jobs --- a big financial impact.

e. Many essential activities have to scale back - eg. military training, public transport commuting (affecting transport industries), MICE activities, social activities like elderly karaoke session, construction (foreign workers cannot travel here to work) projects delayed, foreign diplomacy face-to-face have to cut back etc.

f. Humans have to go out with face masks on, sick people have to serve SHN, maintain social distancing etc ---- which is unnatural to human social interaction in a Society.

 

5. The urge to return to pre-covid state is desirable ---- as humans cannot be slave to the covid forever or in a prolong manner.

 

6. Vaccination looks like our only hope to get humanity back to pre-covid state - to re-commence a normal life - to live, work, educate, socialise, travel, do business etc.

 

7. And humanity have to make preparation to prevent the onslaught of future Disease X.

 

8. Knowing how covid started become important. For eg. if medical scientists are able to discover how covid start --- humanity can in future tackle Disease X at the source eg. if jump host from animals to human ---- humanity must attempt to cut down food source from animals and instead do more R&D in cell-culture food, plant-based meat etc --- and drastically cut down the probability of Disease X from infecting human again.

 

[1:53 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Maybe it's worth looking at clear productivity targets, so people feel their salary is based on contribution rather than time at a desk?

[1:53 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: How has life changed for you in the past year? Have your perspectives about Singapore and being Singaporean changed? How?

Many things have changed. Things we took for granted, like buffets, large family gatherings, movie outings, travel, etc are now almost non-existent. Me and my family have learned to be more resilient and really help out one another in tough times (eg. my newborn falls ill, mother and mother-in-law will come over to help out). We now use WhatsApp chat group to keep each other updated, photos, videos etc.

This year NDP, we should celebrate overcoming this massive global pandemic disaster and forging ahead as a stronger nation. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger. Stay safe everyone. My 2.14 cents.

[1:53 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Also a productivity target keeps things clear and honest between staff and manager. Both parties know the expectations.

[1:55 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes

[1:56 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: Both. As a professional, it’s your time and also the output to meet the target. It’s not mutually exclusive

[1:56 pm, 07/04/2021] +Stella Yip: Be careful though, this might drive short term targets but not long term sustainability. Look at what happened to Credit Suisse, Archegos, and others.

[1:58 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: using accounting as example. Source document in office but you need to documents to completely close or do your accounts. Provided all documents are digitalised and in cloud but not all company able to do that as of last year

 

[2:00 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

According to many neutral reports --- worldwide productivity has fallen as a result of working at home due to covid. https://voxeu.org/article/covid-crisis-and-productivity-growth

 

[2:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: not that it's mutually exclusive, cos it's pointless if you've paid for my time but not my output, then i'm still getting paid twiddling thumbs, also not right. but if the value is the output, if i can get the work out and i remain contactable, does it really matter where i'm doing the work? a company/boss will never complain if the staff works until 1am from home, but will complain for coming in at 9.30? again it depends on the job and what's required, but certain roles really don't require that strict adherence to timing

[2:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: Putting documents in cloud pose another issue for MNC as the servers in cloud is in China may pose some legalistic issues with American law

 

[2:01 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.techrepublic.com/article/long-term-remote-work-is-leading-to-a-global-drop-in-productivity/                                                                                                                                                  Productivity drop as a result of remote working at home due to covid.

 

[2:01 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: If you are in service line. This is not possible.

[2:01 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: but if MNC and everything is in a server somewhere, doesn't matter whether you're working from home or from office. unless it's the company's super secure internal-only server.

[2:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: thus i keep saying it depends on the nature of the work...

[2:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: My guess is that these countries had schools closed and then yes I can understand a productivity drop.

[2:03 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: As a analogy, I was once question by a company , can you teach swimming on line ? They won't want to qualified you as a swimmer

[2:03 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: I think backend or back office roles as much as possible WFH where applicable.

 

[2:04 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

I am an advocate of hybrid working arrangement - work in office and at home.

Not entirely at home or entirely in office.

If work remotely entirely at home, boss have othe options like employing cheaper foreign workers.

 

[2:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: yes, and they measure across sectors. so manufacturing and all will be as good as zero productivity, but office-type work may not change much

[2:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: basically, even in training. Practical is important. Won't want my pilot to be online qualified and fly my around

[2:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +james: At the heart of this discussion abt WFH, this is abt engagement and job-fit.

You only need to police people and worry abt whether they are doing their work if they are not engaged in the work that they are doing.

Many people don’t really know why they’re in the jobs they’re doing. It’s just work to them. As opposed to smthg they truly want to be doing and getting better at.

[2:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: For services and frontliners, no choice need to work in onsite.

[2:05 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: The other aspect is that , WFH shows that your job can be Global ... meaning can be outsourced to cheaper countries and the person doing the job don't need to reside in Singapore and all the quota issue

[2:06 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: If that's the case, most of us would have been jobless by now since most companies can just outsource overseas.

 

[2:06 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8766175/One-four-businesses-report-loss-productivity-employees-work-home-COVID.html                                                                                           Too many reports - reporting loss in productivity when employees work from home during Covid.    My experience also feel the same. The outcomes produce is not as good as hybrid arrangement of WFH and in office.

 

[2:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Instead, MNCs are actually coming in SG to set up as HQ in the region.

[2:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: yep, there's a chinese saying that you employ the people you trust and you trust the people you employ. if have to micromanage and it's that calculative, then the employee also sian. you insist i log on zhun zhun at 9, i will zhun zhun log on at 6. not my words, but relaying the sentiment from some friends

[2:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +Boon: Well, i would guess so if not for MOM policies

[2:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: We therefore welcome them and cannot close our doors. If no enough of talents here we need to import those in for the new roles.

[2:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Sorry what policies you referring to?

[2:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: I don't think MOM have any policy that restricts outsourcing

[2:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: This is an option for bosses to take if our singapore advantage no longer exists

[2:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i would believe that there is a certain value add that we bring as singapore employees because of our culture and work ethics that you don't get in some other outsource locations...

[2:09 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Can you tell me what Singapore advantages are?

[2:09 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: This is especially true for IT line of work

[2:10 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Yes definitely. Good governance, rule of law, least corruption, educated populace, etc

 

[2:11 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/us-productivity-posts-biggest-drop-since-1981-in-fourth-quarter-14113390                                                                                                               See actual statistics don't lie. Cannot imagine productivity can improve while entirely working at home.

 

[2:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +Thomas: The WFH has shown the Company, that we do not need large office. The shenton way offices will be in glut. This is happening in HK. A potential cost saving for company but the stationery costs, we bear for those WFH.

[2:13 pm, 07/04/2021] +Boon: ��

 

[2:17 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

And the negative GDP is the biggest indicator how production has fallen worldwide since covid start.

Thus it is difficult to convince me that working entirely at home improve productivity.

 

[2:20 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Because with no economic activities through human interaction, multiplier effects will not happen - transport, f&b, shopping activities, sales activities, property rental etc...

Demultipier effect kick in - how will economy productivity improve?

Cannot imagine.

 

[2:34 pm, 07/04/2021] +james: Yes that’s a good saying!

If u choose to employ someone, you shld trust them to get the work done. If u can’t trust them, u shldnt employ them.

 

[2:36 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1. Some industries can totally go bankrupt eg. Airlines, taxi, private hire, tourism, office space etc.

2. Many businesses fail, many people lose jobs.

3. With lower or no income, less spending power to purchase other goods and services - overall economy and other business sectors impacted.

4. Overall Economy production fall, more business fail, more jobs loss in other industry sectors.

5. Demultipier effect kicks in, production fall and productivity fall

6. This is an overall negative impact if everyone work at home.

 

[2:46 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1. How is productivity calculated? It is output divided by man hour.

2. If some industries have near zero production, divided by so many man hours - then productivity go into deep negative.

3. With zero income - spending power drop, demand for other goods and services drop.

4. So production in other sectors also drop due to lower demand.

With man hours no change, how can productivity in other sectors and the whole Economy improve?

5. Economic fundamental prove that productivity cannot improve if everyone work at home.

 

[2:54 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Let’s face it, normalcy days are gone. I don’t think we will ever hit back to 100% capacity back to normal again. Nat said before the normalcy train have left the station. We should use this “new normal” to kickstart new sectors and services.

[2:58 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: True to some degree, but also means we can bid for work anywhere in the world. The advantage is with Singapore being an English speaking nation, well educated and global cultures. We are very adaptable, hard working and tolerant.

[2:59 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: I think we are saying there should be a balance of office and home time depending on your role, people interaction and  reporting/strategy

[2:59 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i agree!! some companies may want to have a hub location set up in APAC for reporting into the HQ. Singapore is a great option because of our connectivity, education and english competency

[3:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: And most friendly business environment in the world

[3:01 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: yeah, and stable from a policy perspective too.

[3:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yep, important to have stable government

[3:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Also well managed media and privacy laws

[3:03 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: and good dispute resolution and court system.

[3:03 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Welcome to Singapore! ���� ��

[3:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: so all things considered, i do think we're very global and if we want to, we can venture out

[3:09 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: I few things I can see is we could:

1) Venture out as expat and gain experience. Wait for local MNC to expand there and spearhead the business.

2) Get our local MNC to start up overseas and transfer our people over there.

3) Create new industry and services here and let it take off and expand overseas.

I think end game should be out businesses going overseas to capture bigger market share.

My 2.14cents

[4:16 pm, 07/04/2021] +REACH: [Sent by Gov.sg – 7 Apr]

As of 12pm, MOH has preliminarily confirmed 1 new case of locally transmitted COVID-19 infection.

Based on investigations so far, the case is in the community, and there are no new cases in the dormitories.

There are 34 imported cases, who had already been placed on Stay-Home Notice or isolated upon arrival in Singapore. In total, there are 35 new cases of COVID-19 infection in Singapore today.

MOH will share further updates in its press release that will be issued later tonight.

go.gov.sg/moh070421update

[4:17 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: oh dear

[4:17 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: I hope we will not need to go into another CB

[4:17 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: or some trip

[4:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: as long as imported cases are ring fenced should be ok

[4:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Suma Pamu: Just read this.. Didn't know if Already here Discussion happened about this or not..

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/moe-schools-merging-new-town-tanglin-telok-kurau-14573328

 

[4:18 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1. When boss see the production fall, revenue fall, profit fall, productivity fall - but labor cost constant and still so high - what will the boss think and do?

Reduce labor cost.

 

2. Especially when government subsidies job inventive ends in Jun or September this year.

 

3. By :-

a. Cutting labor

b. Reduce wages

c. Employ cheaper foreign workers that can work remotely at home to replace local staff that work at home.

 

4. That's why when government ask workers to go back to work and some still insist on work from home - soon some can permanently stay at home (shake legs) - status change from WFH to SAH (stay at home).

 

[4:26 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Because bosses are working out and looking at their financial health quarterly.

What tilt them to act is the figures that appear to them.

Jun is just 2 months away. When the job incentive is gone, the figure go south, and some may act.

Let me relate what the boss will do.

 

[4:37 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

As expected, tourism vouchers take up rate quite low.

3/4 still not used.

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/singaporediscovers-vouchers-not-used-expire-end-june-redemption-14561562

 

[4:39 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

No decision to extend the tourism vouchers deadline yet.

 

[4:39 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

When it ends in Jun 2021.

 

[4:40 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: hope can give 2nd round

[4:40 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: boost the local tourism

[4:42 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: some of the "offers" actually very boh hua. like 100+ for an "influencer" to take you on a walking tour down a couple of streets??

[4:43 pm, 07/04/2021] +Rama: agree

[4:43 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: most ppl hoot for staycay only

[4:44 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: but those with many kids or newborns likely hard to do that

[4:44 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i also hoot staycay cos everything else really quite meh

[4:44 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: attraction operating hours should be extended as well, maybe with 75% back to office their operating hours longer now

[4:45 pm, 07/04/2021] +Eunice Chia: there are some that includes a meal....like this labrador park....

https://www.klook.com/en-SG/activity/53510-labrador-park-walking-walking-tour-seafood-buffet-dinner-singapore/

[4:49 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: even if you take into account the cost of the buffet, you're still paying to do a walk which could otherwise be free if you had gone yourself...

[4:51 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Shame they cant take advantage of the declining birth rate to reduce class sizes. My kid's school is being closed and he will start his final year P6 at a new location twice as far away.  Is this really the right approach, or is it a cost saving exercise? The school was just renovated 4 years ago!

[4:55 pm, 07/04/2021] +Suma Pamu: This way If demographics keep continue, it will be nore tough in future, depiste Keep merging or closing school.

Before its too late

More to be done.

HDB should look Into Incorporate All Types of housing in all estates.

Also Redevelopment of Old estates by SERS...that way at least in future

All age Groups will be spread across Singapore.

[4:57 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: yes, my friends who are teachers are also saying that the class sizes could be reduced..

[5:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Rama: Worth considering

[5:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +YT: Hope SingapoRediscovers vouchers expiry date can be extended.

[5:13 pm, 07/04/2021] +Caleb: hope can give a 2nd time, for those who have used up the 1st round.

[5:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Eunice Chia: I believe the walking tour will include introduction to history, heritage etc.... Which may be interesting -- really for locals to rediscover Singapore.

[5:19 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: but... wikipedia............ ��

 

[5:26 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

1. I think Moe has made a study that academic outcomes don't differ from our class size compare to country with smaller class size.

2. In fact Singapore overall results do better than many countries.

3. More schools means more government funding needed.

Means taxpayers will have to pay more taxes eg. Gst, income tax, corporate taxes etc.

4. Manpower shortage means less teachers can be recruited, unless employing more foreign teachers.

Again more teachers needed means more funds needed and translate to more taxes on taxpayers.

 

[5:29 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.todayonline.com/singapore/moe-cautious-issue-smaller-class-sizes-ong-ye-kung

MOE 'cautious' on issue of smaller class sizes: Ong Ye Kung

 

[5:32 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

When unused schools are released as State lands - our land reserves increase.

Next time when sold for commercial used, our sovereign wealth increase - and can be invested to earn more income and NIRC to fund government spending.

 

[5:36 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://whichschooladvisor.com/singapore/school-news/2019-ib-results-singapore-students-celebrate-above-global-average-points                                                                                                                 Singapore schools score above average globally.

 

[5:37 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/singapore-s-15-year-olds-rank-second-globally-in-reading-maths-12147856

Singapore's 15-year-olds rank second globally in reading, maths and science: Study

 

[5:38 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: don't just look at results.. look at how hard the teachers are working to maintain that "KPI"...

 

[5:39 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

https://www.msn.com/en-sg/news/singapore/nus-ntu-amongst-top-15-in-qs-world-ranking/ar-BB1egDbB                                                                                                                                                     NUS and NTU rank among top 15 in the World. And both top Asia University ranking - beating China, Japan and HongKong.

 

[5:40 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Well if taxpayers are willing to pay more tax and willing to employ foreign teachers.

 

[5:46 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i can't quite see how this is relevant? the schools are merging, class sizes remain the same, therefore there are less teachers needed right? from what i know, MOE's intake has unofficially reduced but not for lack of interest/applicants

 

[5:47 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

So that is good, less teachers needed, then they can join other sectors that need manpower like ICT, healthcare, etc.

 

[5:48 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes and those kids will all be doing additional enrichment classes that cramp their childhood and burden their parents wallets.

[5:49 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i'm sorry, i'm blinking very hard right now. so less teachers good, but if want to reduce class size, have to bring in foreign teachers. huh????

[5:49 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: MOE studying their own results doesn't sound very independent to me

[5:50 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: If we measure our kids on maths science and English then sure they no doubt do very well. Is that what is needed in our years ahead? What happened to creative thinking, social problem solving, risk taking and people management?

[5:51 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Technology means we don't need to memorise facts and information. Our kids are taken down a narrow path, and those that are different (not academic) are shut off from opportunity.

 

[5:54 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

As far as I know, those in the Universities very creative.

Some do all sort of research papers that are quite cutting edge.

And some end up in R&D in high tech companies doing cutting edge research.

 

[5:54 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: I'm not saying it's all about class sizes at all. Education is a complex subject and relying on 'results' alone is not a good metric to follow

[5:54 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Correct, these are the star pupils who are good at everything

 

[5:55 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Compare to the world, we are proud to be on the right track.

Even US and UK are curious how we did it.

 

[5:55 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: We are in a meritocracy, which leans towards those who do well in Maths, Science and English

[5:56 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes, but this is largely due to other circumstances and is only measured on exam results

[5:56 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Why are we so reliant on foreign 'talent' for key jobs?

[5:58 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Enrichment classes and a compliant attitude in the class room.

[6:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alex: Because education is too focused towards teaching kids to pass exams rather than to think for themselves.

[6:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: the kids aren't learning to understand the subject, they're learning how to crack exams

 

[6:01 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

We merge many JCs together - because of low birth rate.

1. We maintain the same class size.

2. We don't deliberately maintain so many JCs - when we can reduce the number of JCs by half.

3. So we save the state lands 6 or more plots of lands.

4. We cut the number of teachers by half (more than hundred?) - and can redeploy for other jobs.

Else we need to maintain the redundant additional hundred of teachers just to make the class size small.

5. Imagine the amount of salary save and the revenue state lands earn by taxpayers?

 

[6:01 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Exactly

[6:01 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes, that's how it seems

[6:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Very short term thinking. Not good for SG future

[6:02 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Investing in our kids should be number 1.

 

[6:04 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Well I am proud of our school system - because all my family members and extended families members are producing scholar, researchers, engineers, lawyer, living science, IT professionals etc.

All should be considered creative and innovative.

 

[6:04 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Otherwise only those who can afford enrichment will benefit and others left behind. Lots of missed opportunity comes from that.

 

[6:05 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

My kid don't take tuition or enrichment classes.

 

[6:05 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: You are very fortunate and in a great position. It's not a criticism of you or your family. The world is changing and our education system isn't.

[6:05 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Clearly you have good academic genes!

 

[6:07 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Sorry I mean when he was in JC and above.

He took some tuition in secondary school.

 

[6:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: i agree. if our school system is so great, why are the top hats all brought in from overseas and why is there a worry of being "replaced" by foreign talent? so perhaps our school system is great at producing followers but not good at producing thinkers?

[6:07 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: That's right

[6:08 pm, 07/04/2021] +Rama: good point

 

[6:09 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Oh those jobs are thinking jobs not followers job.

Can't be just enter workforce - straight away become CEOs.

 

[6:48 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Oh and a doctor.

 

[6:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: No one is saying CEO straight away. We are I think saying the system is outdated.

[6:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +Anne: You are spot on. Many Singaporeans want to be told what to do. Some authority or “credible” sources tell them something, instead of asking questions, they believe and follow unconditionally.

[6:11 pm, 07/04/2021] +Rama: right on

 

[6:11 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Also my previous neighbor and friend produce 3 government scholars - in our school system. 2 PSC scholars, 1 SAF scholars.

So I don't think our school system are on the wrong track.

 

[6:24 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Now one of them is a CEO.

 

[6:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes this is very common. I come across this with all industries from legal to sales to healthcare

[6:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: You can't pick isolated incidents and claim the whole system is working fine

[6:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: yep. scholar scholar and yet just want to follow SOP. can't deal with deviation and judgment calls

[6:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Of course there are successes

[6:12 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Spot on

 

[6:14 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Singapore civil service is top rated in the world - in case people have doubts.

 

[6:14 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes and this make sense. Civil Sevice is mostly about maintaining order and procedure, as defined by government

 

[6:15 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

And is the best in the world.

 

[6:16 pm, 07/04/2021] +Stella Yip: Some teachers don't like to be questioned, if they don't know the answers bcos they also follow blindly. Then they get defensive. Say students not respectful, deviate, waste time, have difficulty to understand simple concepts etc

[6:16 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Which is excellent, are we all to become civil servants?

[6:16 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes my kids teacher told the students not to ask questions but just do as they are told.

[6:17 pm, 07/04/2021] +Stella Yip: Haha u know the pain

[6:17 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: Our civil service is great because they just follow SOP. any deviation means no go, no go means not added to stats for efficiency

[6:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Correct, which is the role of the civil service and fine. We are in need to entrepreneurs, risk takers, creative thinkers and social managers as well.

[6:18 pm, 07/04/2021] +CQ: Yah lor. That's why even DBS chief is parachuted what

 

[6:19 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Well US top entrepreneurs like Facebook,etc are migrants.

In fact many of their top researchers are migrants.

 

[6:20 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/companies-markets/st-engineering-selected-as-partner-to-produce-prototype-vehicle-for-us-army

 

[6:20 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes they hired people rapidly from all over the world to fuel their growth

[6:21 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes, our engineering is excellent. The school system was devised for engineering as SG needed to build and grow.

[6:22 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Maths science and English

 

[6:22 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Same as Singapore.

Even China with 1.4 billion cannot depends on their own nationals.

They need researchers from other countries.

Eg. Semiconductor, fighter planes engine, commercial planes etc.

 

[6:22 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Ok, that is not what the education debate is about though, unless the intention is to provide engineers for the world?

 

[6:32 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Well many civil servants, MPs, ex-Ministers from overseas also studying in our school, Universities or trained in our civil service college.

 

[6:34 pm, 07/04/2021] +Rama: great

 

[6:34 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/malaysia-syed-saddiq-singapore-nus-lkyspp-muar-muda-14535692      

Malaysia ex-Minister take course in NUS - and interact with Singapore civil service and our Ministers.

 

[6:36 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Even superpower China send their senior civil servants to be trained in our civil service college.

 

[6:36 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心: http://www.china.org.cn/english/2002/Jul/36977.htm

China, Singapore to Cooperate in Training Senior Civil Servants

 

[6:46 pm, 07/04/2021] +REACH: Dear Contributors,

⏰ We will be closing the chat in 15 minutes ⏰

Thank you very much for being part of our WhatsApp chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan

[6:46 pm, 07/04/2021] +Bobby Tan: Good night Megan

 

[6:48 pm, 07/04/2021] ☸️  Danny 心:

Oh and a doctor.

 

[6:50 pm, 07/04/2021] +Alvin Lim: Gdnite Megan

[6:57 pm, 07/04/2021] +Dan: Rush curriculum. Bo pian~ I empathise.

[6:58 pm, 07/04/2021] +Dan: Many teachers play facilitation role now. Gone are the days teacher teach students learn.

[6:59 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: ��

[6:59 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Yes, a study on enrichment use would be interesting

[6:59 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: How many students and how their grades compare

[7:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Teachers say its hard to teach because because range is wide. Kids doing enrichment are ahead of the curriculum.

[7:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +REACH: Dear Contributors,

We will be closing the chat for today.

Thank you very much for being part of our WhatsApp chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan

[7:00 pm, 07/04/2021] +Ben: Night

 

Saturday, April 3, 2021

US-China rivalry could force unwelcome choices on some countries

Observers say Beijing is not trying to create its own camp but aiming to discourage others from aligning with Washington

Smaller nations will need to carefully manage escalating competition between the two powers

Teddy Ng and Rachel Zhang  in Shanghai

SCMP

Published: 12:00pm, 3 Apr, 2021

----


1. Other Countries in the World - many of them have express unwillingness to take sides in US-China geopolitical tension.

2. The reason is simple, why offend 1 power at the expense of the other power - when Countries can work in Win-Win mutually beneficial outcomes with both powers?

3. By selecting and siding one power - at the expense of the other power --- will expedite the collision of the 2 powers.

4. By not taking side, but maintaining a principle stand in dealing with both powers (whether in economic, politics and social engagement) --- will make geopolitical tension less intense ---- as neutral countries will act as a buffer and cushion in preventing the 2 powers from colliding - by not partaking in the 2 powers' power play.

5. The World should learn from historical lessons in World War 1, World War 2 and the Cold war ---- when countries take sides into 2 Blocs - where countries snatch world scarce resources instead of sharing and trading at the expense of the other Blocs, harm one another interest at the expense of the other Blocs and make the World more dangerous  - and will not mutually benefit one another Bloc through trade, investment, business. As a result, World war break out with destruction and death of mammoth proportion.

6. Mutual beneficial trade, investment, business, climate agreement, fighting pandemic through global cooperation, global terrorism and other global issues ---- will be the best global cooperation and collaboration  going forward ----- instead of focusing on one power clobbering another power - for self-interest --- at the expense of global safety, security, peace and the consequence prosperity.


-------

User since May 2019
D. C.
As a smaller country, how to get the most out of the two powers? Well, depending how much USA or China pays, and how long, with the condition that if other side increases offer, either match or cancel? Important strategy is to be flexible and ensure easy cancellation (like USA can terminate any agreement for security reason). Of course, stay away from any military involvement. Let USA fights with China directly, small countries serve as outsiders or observers only. Isn't that good enough?
20h ago
1
---

1. Smaller Countries must not play 1 power against another power - just to reap benefits. This become a "transactional relationship" or "a bribe relationship" ---- that will not be long lasting. 

2. Expecting 1 power to "pay" the smaller Countries more than the other power - so as to gain "friendship" or "support" or "stand on the side" of that power --- does not come from a principle stand, but based on which power has more financial strength and the willingness to splurge the money to "buy" friendship --- will not last - and will not make the World less dangerous or lesser conflict. Because the power that lose out in "buying friendship" --- will create more trouble.

3. Smaller Countries should adopt the following stances in their relationship with the 2 powers:-
a. Forge mutual benefits with the 2 powers.
b. Adopt Win-Win outcome with the 2 powers through :-
- Trade
- Investment
- Business
- Travel
- Tourism
- R&D collaboration
- Resolving climate conditions, pandemic etc

4. Such relationship with the 2 powers - will be more strategic. more longer lasting - as not only the smaller Countries will benefit economically, benefit domestic business, create jobs for their people and grow their GDP. The 2 powers will also similarly benefit economically, making their business vibrant, create jobs and grow their GDP --- indeed a Win-Win outcome.

5. Such relationship between the smaller Countries and the 2 powers - will be more lasting, more strategic, more beneficial, more dignified - than expecting the powers to pay the smaller Countries to stand on their side.

6. Through such web of economic relationship and integration - the 2 powers will less likely to "locked horn" with one another or elicit smaller Countries to clobber the other power --- as every Countries have stakes in the Global Economy ---- and will not want the 2 powers to adopt confrontational stance --- that will hurt the economic interest of all stakeholders.

------
User since May 2019
D. C.
@Babe B. Thanks for your comment. Think it is more on the theoretical n academic side than reality. Are you aware how USA n the West pound the Belt n Silk Road project and want to replace it with their own to constraint China's growth n influence? Small countries can do very little and may have to choose side. And what criteria to use when choosing? Naturally who generates the biggest benefits to its citizens n country. Don't talk moral standards, freedom or democracy, or righteousness, or fairness. The big powers also will not use that. This is a political world, not Utopia. 
12h ago
-----
1. I agree with you that choosing a development project or building an infrastructure - has to be based on merits or benefits to a Country and to its citizens.

2. In addition, I also believe in mutual benefits (as I don't believe in one-sided benefit - which will not last, as there are no free-lumch) - because the power who are financing the project, offering loans, offering technical assistance, co-own or other form of collaboration - will also want to benefit from the projects (such as gaining accessibility, create jobs for its workers, create business opportunities for its companies, bank earn interest from loans, gaining goodwill, trust and winning friendship and cooperation which in turn strenghten its political influence, spur external economic growth etc).

3. Hence, selection of the projects will based on the following considerations to be objective (free from political influence) :-
a. Does the project benefit the Country and its citizen and its Economy
b. Does the Country has the means to repay the infrastructure loan based on the terms of loan
c. Does the Country benefited from technical transfer to be able to operate, and maintain the infrastructure upon completion
d. Does the Country able to collaborate with the powers to participate in other future projects etc.
e. Does the Powers has the financial means to finance the entire programme?
f. Is the programme reliable and will not flip-flop?
Eg. a power coin the concept of a multi-lateral FTA - TPP - and all members sign the FTA.
However, when a new President is elected, the power withdraw from the FTA - and leave the members in the lurch.
If a programme upon roll-out - pose the risk of flip-flop and withdrawal - then smaller Countries will hesitate to participate - because integrity and sincerity to see the programme through is the basic lowest denomination.
Else the programme lose its credibility - and the trust lost is very difficult to regain.

4. Hence to conclude, the above evaluation criteria will be on the mind of smaller Countries whether they will want to participate in the project and which project from which powers.
It will be an objective, technical assessment, financial assessment - professional assessment.
This will make selection - more professional, diplomatic and less likely to choose sides - ensuring the World is less confrontational.

=====


 ====


大乘愿 (Mahayana Bodhi Vows)

3 Apr 2021 (Vows made in 17 Oct  2013)


(总愿) (普愿)- Common Bodhi Vows

“众生无边誓愿度,

烦恼无尽誓愿断,

法门无量誓愿学,

佛道无上誓愿成”

All infinite sentinent beings I vow to salvage.

All infinite vexation I vow to eradicate. (No stray thoughts arise, no stray thoughts can penetrate).

All infinite teachings I vow to learn.

The Supreme Enlightenment I vow to attain!


(别愿) (个愿)- Individual Bodhi Vows

大悲愿

(大悲心, 大愿力)

十方六道(天、人、阿修罗;畜生、饿鬼、地狱)

不空,誓不成佛

十方众生(天、人、阿修罗;畜生、饿鬼、地狱)

渡尽,方证菩提。

十方十法界(六道众生、声闻-四圣人、缘觉- 辟支佛、菩萨、佛) 加持及普渡


1. If all 10 directions 6 realms fail to attain Emptiness, I Vow not to gain Buddhahood.

2. Until all 10 directions sentinent beings are liberated & gain Full Enlightenment, will I enter into Final Nirvana.

3. 10 direction of 10 Dharma realms (6 sentinent beings realms, Saints, Paccekas, Bodhisattvas & Buddhas) provide Blessings & Support.

4. Leave no one in Samsara behind.

5. Leave no matter in Samsara behind.


My 5 Vows to liberate begin from my country, my earth, my universe.


======


Thursday, April 1, 2021

From Big Bang to present: Snapshots of our universe through time

1 Apr 2021

Very beautiful description of how infant universe evolve from Emptiness to the current vast Universe.

It mirror Samadhi Jhana and Nirvana fruition.

1 Supreme Enlightened Creator - 1 Samsara Universe.

Infinite Supreme Enlightened Creators - Infinite Parallel Samsara Universes.
















Coronavirus: Chinese, WHO scientists were ‘in it together’ in Wuhan

Liang Wannian, who led Chinese side in joint investigation, dismisses claims members of international team were denied access to data

Report on inquiry was delayed ‘not because of any interference or our laziness’ but because those involved were ‘striving to ensure its quality’, he says

Holly Chik

SCMP

Published: 8:16pm, 31 Mar, 2021

-------

1. The explanation by China why data are delayed and why some privacy data can be accessed and read but cannot be taken away - look above board and reasonable. China can stand tall or no need to look small.


2. Many Countries - whether democratic Countries or not - also have privacy law to protect some data that are sensitive to the citizens.

China allowing WHO medical team to access and read - but not to be taken away - is reasonable and above board - as long as the report and investigation can discover the origin of the covid and not alter the report that is not the truth.


3. The explanation of ensuring data quality and hence result in delay - is also acceptable - as unstructured raw data can cause confusion --- as long as the format and organisation of the data does not distort the truth.


4. As the WHO team leader who led the medical team publicly concur with China's explanation - this make China's public statement credible. I can't see any ground to fault China.


5. Let us come back to the objectives of the WHO's investigation :-

a. To determine the origin of covid and what trigger this horrible disease.

b. The result of the investigation - will help the World to come out with process, system, procedures, R&D on clinical prevention etc - to prepare ourselves and protect Humanity from future Disease X pandemic - that can cause global death and illness --- so that the World in future will not get caught flat-footed.

c. WHO investigation is not to pin blame on any Country or Countries or to demand compensation - as this will cause Country or Countries to be defensive, not cooperating (and the World will not be able to find the root cause - that will be usefulg to prevent future pandemic) - especially if the pandemic occur through nature.

The World has to remember that H1N1 that trigger a pandemic worldwide in 2009 infect 1.4 billion people causing 575,400 death.

Did the World pin the blame on the originator - as it occur naturally in animals that jump host to human?

d. WHO investigation must be fair, neutral, objective and evidence-based - free from political influence.

e. Most importantly - this WHO investigation of the covid orign should not be influence by "power play" and allow itself to be "politicised" ---- because it will distort the mission of covid investigation of discovering how it occur, and how to prevent future Disease X. Future cooperation to combat future pandemic will not be forthcoming if this is compromise --- and this will be detrimental to the global public health and safety to Humanity - if this investigation is politicised.

Neutral Countries in the World - should not be draw into a "power play" --- rather than cooperation to safeguard Humanity from future pandemic.

Neutral Countries should not be used as "pawn" for such political purpose. In other word, "power play" should be outside the equation of this WHO covid investigation.


6. When WHO investigation is neutral, unbias and is conduct fairly - then China and in future other Countries will be cooperative and forthcoming - in the event if future similar pandemic arise --- so that pandemic can be quickly arrested, prevented from escalation - that will help to reduce casaulties worldwide.


7. The other outcomes of WHO fair, unbias and objective investigation in cooperation with China - will help to promote confidence and constructiveness in engaging World Bodies to resolve complex global problem ---- as the outcomes is to ensure Win-Win outcomes for Humanity --- not to clobber another Country based on coercion from another power, or to receive geopolitical gain by putting down another Country.

Only then Countries will more likely to open up, cooperate and forthcoming to work with Global Bodies --- to resolve thorny complex global issues and problems --- without resorting to conflict, confrontation and destructive actions --- that lead to a more dangerous World. 


8. Countries will also more likely to comply with International Rules --- as the rules are not formulated to benefit some powers - but to benefit International members at large --- in resolving international disputes. In so doing, the World will be more peaceful, constructive and Countries can work together to resolve global issues - without resorting to unwholesome confrontation that destabilise the World.