REACH (Telegram) 59 - Budget 2025.
The Budget - themed Onward Together For A Better Tomorrow, will advance Singapore’s plans for a “stronger and more united society”, as outlined in the Forward Singapore report.
(SK)
18 Feb 2025 (10am - 7pm)
REACH (Telegram)
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 10:00 AM]
π’ BUDGET SPEECH TODAY @ 3.30PM
PM & Finance Minister Lawrence Wong will be delivering the Budget 2025 speech in Parliament today at 3.30pm.
This Telegram Chat group will be open at 3.30pm for contributors to discuss and share their views about Budget 2025 measures.
The Budget - themed Onward Together For A Better Tomorrow, will advance Singapore’s plans for a “stronger and more united society”, as outlined in the Forward Singapore report.
It looks at how the Government can:
(1) Develop a more vibrant business ecosystem π
(2) Provide Opportunities for Skills Upgrading and Jobs for Workers π
(3) Support Singaporeans across different life stages π€
(4) Strengthen Singaporeans' sense of solidarity and unity as the nation celebrates SG60πͺπ»
π Watch the Budget speech live at 3.30pm: https://www.youtube.com/live/fE4gfFO3hgc?si=34YZswK2hNQK_6kG
ππ» For more info on Budget 2025, please visit MOF's Singapore Budget website at https://www.mof.gov.sg/singaporebudget.
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 3:30 PM]
π’ SHARE YOUR VIEWS HERE ON THE BUDGET 2025 SPEECH π’
PM & Finance Minister Lawrence Wong is delivering the Budget 2025 speech now in Parliament. Watch the speech live (https://www.youtube.com/live/fE4gfFO3hgc?si=34YZswK2hNQK_6kG) and share your views on Budget 2025 measures here!
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 4:01 PM]
π’ [SHARE YOUR VIEWS #1] BUDGET 2025 - Tackling Cost Pressures
PM & Finance Minister Lawrence Wong had just announced a slate of measures to tackle cost pressures.
π¬ What are your views on the measures to tackle cost pressures?
The measures include:
π Additional $800 in CDC Vouchers for all Singaporean households - the first $500 will be disbursed in May 2025, and the remaining $300 will be disbursed in January 2026.
π Additional U Save rebates of up to $760 to help HDB households cope with increase in utility bills
π $500 LifeSG credits for each Singaporean child age 12 and below. The credits can be used for groceries, utilities and pharmacy items.
π $500 Edusave or Post-Secondary Education Account top-up for every Singaporean aged 13 to 20 this year.
π Increased rates for ComCare Assistance Schemes
π MND to launch 50,000 new flats over the next 3 years
π 50 per cent corporate income tax rebate for 2025. Non-profitable companies that will not benefit from the rebate will be provided with a minimum benefit of S$2,000, capped at S$40,000 per company.
π https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/singapore-budget-2025-lawrence-wong-live-blog-4938461
----
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:10 PM]
1. Yesterday REACH topic - talk about individual income and household income.
2. Today's topic Budget 2025 - talk about Government grants and transfer.
3. Both Income apparatus (Self + Government) - are design to support the livelihood of a family + cushion the household against inflation.
4. Self *income* - support the living expenses of the family.
Government transfer - cushion the household against higher inflation.
5. So tackling our current high cost of living due to higher inflation - both topics are a perfect formula.
(δΈθ°θε).
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:10 PM]
My only concern in this "2 legged inflation buster" are :-
1. Job security - to ensure employment income are not affected when tech or business disruptors hit.
If do hit, remedies must be available to help individuals and household to quickly recover.
2. Sustainability of Government grants and transfer - year after year (as long as inflation are threatening our population)?
Daniel, [18/2/2025 4:23 PM]
As a parent, I do appreciate the LifeSG credits. Especially since it's on a per child basis instead of per household, this will certainly help.
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 4:30 PM]
π’ [SHARE YOUR VIEWS #2] BUDGET 2025 - Advancing our growth frontier
PM & Finance Minister Lawrence Wong had just announced a slate of measures to advance Singapore's growth frontier to promote economic growth.
π¬ What are your views on the measures to promote economic growth?
The measures include:
π S$3 billion top-up to National Productivity Fund
π S$150 million will be put aside for a new Enterprise Compute Initiative
π S$5 billion top-up for Changi Airport Development Fund to develop Singapore’s air hub, which is a key pillar of connectivity.
π S$5 billion boost to Future Energy Fund - to support infrastructure investments for Singapore’s energy transition towards a net-zero future
π https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/singapore-budget-2025-lawrence-wong-live-blog-4938461
Muhamed Shadiq, [18/2/2025 4:36 PM]
The additional CDC voucher is commendable. It could become an integral and permanent feature in supporting families to defray their daily expenses. The gaps between each injection of CDC voucher could be narrower to provide the relief.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:39 PM]
Notice GST vouchers are not announced.
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 4:39 PM]
[SHARE YOUR VIEWS #3] Equipping Workers Throughout Life
To continue supporting the development of our workers and ensure that Singaporeans are equipped with the skills needed to stay competitive and relevant in the workforce, the Government will:
✅ Encourage lifelong learning
✅ Support our enterprises in workforce transformation
✅ Strengthen support for our workers
π¬ What are your views on the measures to promote lifelong learning and skills upgrading?
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:50 PM]
1. Also noticed that Singapore is seriously looking into nuclear power for our clean energy needs.
2. Notably SMR (small module reactor) likely to be nuclear fission.
3. Hence safety need to be look into to assure population such nuclear power is safe for us even though SMR is touted to be safe.
Because nuclear fission to produce heat and generate electricity by breaking up atoms and sub-atomic structure produce radioactive waste.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:52 PM]
SG60 vouchers announced $600, $800.
New items.
Wonder how is this look like.
SG60 replacing GST vouchers?
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 4:54 PM]
[SHARE YOUR VIEWS #4] Building a Sustainable City
π³ To build a sustainable future, the Government will accelerate efforts to decarbonise our economy and enhance our climate resilience by:
πΏ Adapting to climate change
πΏ Greening our transport sector
πΏ Embracing sustainability for all
π¬ What are your views on the measures by the Government to build a more sustainable city?
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 4:56 PM]
$400 climate vouchers not only for HDB households but also for private households are fair.
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:00 PM]
What does 100 top up mean?
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 5:13 PM]
[SHARE YOUR VIEWS #5] Nurturing a Caring and Inclusive Society
A major part of the Forward Singapore agenda is to nurture a more caring and inclusive society – one where every Singaporean feels valued and supported, regardless of age, ability and circumstance π
In Budget 2025, the Government will:
π Build a Singapore Made for Families
π Enable seniors to age well
π Improve the resilience of vulnerable families
π Empower persons with disabilities
π¬ What are your views on the measures by the Government to nurture a more caring and inclusive society?
83Suma Propnex, [18/2/2025 5:19 PM]
Wow.very surprised.
Totally ignored about Housing prices :)
The Household income raised, seems Housing is very affordable now.
May be i was wrong to think housing prices not normal...
750-k 850k For 5 rm in Punggol seems Normal to Minister. And Million dollor is just a fraction.
Over 2000psf in OCR new launch is new normal.
Ok
Now i change mindset LOL
RY, [18/2/2025 5:37 PM]
Glad to see Govt is enhancing financial support to caregivers, whom unlikely to work full-time due to caregiving role for family
And also people with disability/special need adults
SG is going towards a more inclusive society and tackling ageing problem
Ahin, [18/2/2025 5:39 PM]
I hope for more disability / special need adults support... especially in the rising of cost of living
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 5:41 PM]
[ Poll : Which theme(s) in Budget 2025 resonated with you the most? (You may choose more than one option) Please share your reasons in the chat! ]
- Tackling cost pressures
- Advancing our Growth Frontier
- Equipping workers throughout life
- Building a sustainable city
- Nurturing a caring and inclusive society
- Rallying as One United People
RY, [18/2/2025 5:42 PM]
These areas Govt rarely touch on in past Budget .....
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:48 PM]
Wonder why they dont talk about household expenditure. If 2 income household rise so much, how much would such a household spend?
Is the gov implying that dual income families and dinks should be lumped in the same category for statistics?
μ¬μμΉκ΅¬, 첫μ¬λ π, [18/2/2025 5:48 PM]
The election is between may to july.
Noor Naffissah, [18/2/2025 5:49 PM]
It's in may the election
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:49 PM]
The reality is, large and low income households have way horrible statistics. Imagine infltion multiplied by each member in the family whether working or not
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:51 PM]
I wanna talk about the skillsfuture thingy because it looks like something the govt can realisticly make change for now
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:51 PM]
I think the money should only go into courses that are accredited and really increase employability
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:52 PM]
If the job requirements did not ask for the course, why does it exist?
Noor Naffissah, [18/2/2025 5:52 PM]
If government top up the skill future credit for 30 yrs old and above will be great..
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:53 PM]
Problem is skillfuture really looks like something to sustain education businesses that otherwise wouldnt survive in a real free economy
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:53 PM]
If i could spend it on exams for certificates employers really look for, i would
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:55 PM]
They need some kind of better metric and standards for skillsfuture courses
Adam, [18/2/2025 5:58 PM]
Btw i wonder what to spend for the culture and activesg credits. I hope they have some marketing for events to spend it on
Local, [18/2/2025 6:02 PM]
This budget indeed for everyone. Private property owners also have $400 climate vouchers…
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 6:05 PM]
[SHARE YOUR VIEWS #6] Rallying as One United People
This year, we celebrate SG60! πΈπ¬
The Government will be:
✅ Recognising Singaporeans’ contributions and sharing the benefits of our nation’s progress
✅ Strengthening our national identity and community bonds
π¬What are your views on the SG60 Package and the Government's efforts to strengthen community bonds?
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:05 PM]
I think quite a number of skillfuture courses can secure employment.
Eg. Cissp - certified IT security course.
Ccie - certified network expert course.
Professional certificate in machine learning using python.
RY, [18/2/2025 6:06 PM]
CDC voucher also apply to every singapore household, whether staying HDB/private
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:08 PM]
I believe your concern is, should there be a closer tie up between education course through skillfuture with employers.
That's upon successful completion of course can be placed into jobs.
I think coming from this angle, skillfuture courses will be more reassuring for people who intend to reskill or upskill - that a job is guaranteed for them after completing the course.
That's train-and-placement skillfuture training courses are what many workers are looking for.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:17 PM]
Interesting to note that based on the government spending trends - it has increased from 15% to 18% of GDP.
Year 2030 will increase to 20% of GDP.
Our GDP is US$514 billion in 2024. (S$688.76 billion).
2024 fiscal budget is S$112.9 billion.
2025 if 18% will be $123 billion (estimated).
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:21 PM]
GST contributed $20.6 Billion to the government revenue.
(2nd largest revenue source).
Else cannot funds the ever increasing government spendings.
Though GST is unpopular but broad based.
Andrew Goh, [18/2/2025 6:24 PM]
On the topic of sustainability, car owners are encouraged to adopt Electric Cars.
Is it necessary to have the AFC meant for ICE?
Source: https://onemotoring.lta.gov.sg/content/onemotoring/home/buying/upfront-vehicle-costs/tax-structure.html
As announced at Budget 2020, fully electric vehicles are levied with an Additional Flat Component (AFC) to partially cover the fuel excise duties paid by equivalent Internal Combustion Engine vehicles. The AFC is payable as part of road tax at each renewal.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:32 PM]
Budget 2025: 'Considerable' uncertainty about Singapore government revenues in coming years, says PM Wong
Corporate income tax collections increased unexpectedly in recent years, but it is too soon to tell whether this will be a lasting trend, said Prime Minister and Finance Minister Lawrence Wong.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:32 PM]
This is really my worries.
μ¬μμΉκ΅¬, 첫μ¬λ π, [18/2/2025 6:33 PM]
But thinking about it they're probably trynna convince certain groups more to vote for them haha.
μ¬μμΉκ΅¬, 첫μ¬λ π, [18/2/2025 6:34 PM]
I think the EV subsidies are nice but I wished they would tax the petrol cars? Not sure if it exists now.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:34 PM]
Wonder why sometimes people tend to indulge in conspiracy theories rather than government genuine intention to be inclusive.
Unfair to those working in civil service and public office if people have such thoughts - whereby these people are there to serve the population.
Daniel, [18/2/2025 6:35 PM]
I think it's part of the tax on petrol.
Andy, [18/2/2025 6:35 PM]
Sustainability while a good cause, needs to make monetary sense if they want to drive uptake
μ¬μμΉκ΅¬, 첫μ¬λ π, [18/2/2025 6:35 PM]
There's a current tax on it now to encourage people to switch to EVs?
Andy, [18/2/2025 6:36 PM]
I don't think the EV discounts are significant enough to drive high adoption.
Daniel, [18/2/2025 6:36 PM]
No, but petrol tax is higher than that overall I think.
Andrew Goh, [18/2/2025 6:36 PM]
Yes, EV owners have to pay the AFC tax.
Daniel, [18/2/2025 6:37 PM]
Because EV still use more space and infrastructure than public transport, so make sense have to contribute.
Andy, [18/2/2025 6:37 PM]
Anyway, only a minority own cars. Doesn't affect most. Making public transport green and sustainable will have greater effect on the cause
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 6:44 PM]
When government are tighter in fiscal budget - government will try to help the vulnerable and lower income people.
When budget are better, government will try to be inclusive to reach out to other strata of the population - which include the higher income people who contributed significantly to the government revenue in paying taxes that benefit everyone.
Hence we should give credits to government effort to try to be inclusive - regardless of population strata as long as the budget allows.
This is the values endear in civil service and public office - and we should pay tribute to the government effort for doing so.
$400 to high income earners are peanut to them, it won't sway these people to vote for the incumbent if they are not willing to do so.
But it is the right values, the right principles, the right heart that drive the government policies - to act what it says - to be *Inclusive* to reach out to all strata of the population when budget permits.
Andy, [18/2/2025 6:52 PM]
Not surprised about the #1 option. We are all directly affected and hence all can relate.
I think more importantly, we need to foresee the near-future challenges and start to combat it. For me its the aging population and declining birth rates.
We have to build a Singapore that has strong elderly care and support. Children all have to work as dual income families and won't be able to look after parents 24/7.
Also, family friendly and encourage couples to have children. Otherwise you will see more and more foreigners coming in.CH (Telegram)
G, [18/2/2025 7:19 PM]
Nothing mentioned about budget cuts for govt profligate spending
What's being done to cut unnecessary govt spending?
Which are the areas in govt where fats are to be trimmed?
Which stat boards / departments are being cut / downsized?
Which pet projects have stopped?
How much have been saved from reduced govt spending?
I'd very much rather the govt cut spending, than to continue in their ways and spend more, raise taxes to feed their spending, which contributes to driving up costs of living, then having to spend more public money to administer hand outs because of rising costs of living
RY, [18/2/2025 7:20 PM]
I am overall happy that this year Budget covers a very comprehensive aspects in most areas eg SG Enabled
RY, [18/2/2025 7:22 PM]
We are anticipating GE in 2025 likely, maybe right after SG60 celebration .....
RY, [18/2/2025 7:25 PM]
Temasek/GiC profits contribute quite a lumpsum to SG Reserves/Budget,
Hence we getting money fm Govt almost yearly
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:26 PM]
Singapore tops global civil service ranking
Singapore has come out on top of a new ranking of the performance of 120 public administrations around the world, with Denmark, Canada, Norway and Finland completing the top five.
The new index, which has been produced by the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford, rates countries on four themes – strategy and leadership, public policy, national delivery, and people and processes.
Leo Yip, head of Singapore’s civil service, said that he was “humbled” that Singapore’s public administration was highly rated in the inaugural index.
“We in the Singapore civil service have learned so much from the best practice of counterparts and public services around the world. The index is an important effort to help us learn from one another and improve our own effectiveness, in order to serve our peoples better”, he added.
RY, [18/2/2025 7:26 PM]
SG Budget is always very targetted and focused, that means our Govt is very prudent in spending also
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:27 PM]
Wonder which statutory boards and agencies need to cut - as singapore civil service is the most optimally size in the world.
Jun Ming, [18/2/2025 7:28 PM]
I hope to have tengah forest estate forested
Andy, [18/2/2025 7:28 PM]
Like plant back all the trees? Haha
Jun Ming, [18/2/2025 7:30 PM]
Instead keep focusing of electric cars which I am in doubt if it is truly sustainable please focus more on nature based solutions
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:33 PM]
I disagree on this statement. How can perfection occur? I don't know which, but for sure there are area we need to look into.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:33 PM]
Example which one?
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:35 PM]
There are area that can be look into. This qn is as good as how u know our system is the most optimally size in the world.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:36 PM]
All statutory boards and government agencies are established by Act of Parliament.
And each agencies are established to serve unique purpose.
Which one you think need to cut?
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:37 PM]
Statutory boards and government agencies in Singapore are established by Acts of Parliament to perform specific functions. These organizations are autonomous, but still report to a specific ministry and are accountable to the government ¹.
*Examples of Statutory Boards:*
- _Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA)_
- _Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*STAR)_
- _Building and Construction Authority (BCA)_
- _Central Provident Fund Board (CPF)_
- _Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (CAAS)_
- _Economic Development Board (EDB)_
- _Energy Market Authority (EMA)_
- _Health Promotion Board (HPB)_
- _Housing and Development Board (HDB)_
- _Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA)_
- _Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (IRAS)_
- _Land Transport Authority (LTA)_
- _Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA)_
- _Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS)_
- _National Environment Agency (NEA)_
- _National Parks Board (NParks)_
- _People's Association (PA)_
- _Public Utilities Board (PUB)_
- _Singapore Food Agency (SFA)_
- _Singapore Tourism Board (STB)_
- _SkillsFuture Singapore (SSG)_
- _Sport Singapore (SPORTSG)_
- _Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA)_
These statutory boards play a crucial role in implementing policies and programs in various sectors, providing essential services, and regulating key industries ¹.
Source:- Meta AI, Wikipedia
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:37 PM]
Which one to cut?
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:38 PM]
U had a good run π
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:40 PM]
Just that we hope not to be like Elon Musk doge anyhow cut and cut blindly.
Until commercial airplanes crash 4 times in a month when federal safety aviation staff are chop off leading to air flight safety crisis.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:43 PM]
Because if someone foul up a company, the worst consequences is bankrupt and job losses.
If someone foul up the Government, the consequences will be loss of lives, loss of livelihood, social unrest, terrorism breakthrough - a matter of life and death.
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 7:45 PM]
Dear Contributors,
⏰ We will be closing the chat in 15 minutes ⏰
Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.
Goodnight!
Megan π
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:47 PM]
Let's not be too defensive and pressing on certain point but rather open a little. Maybe a little fine tune makes our Singapore a better place to live.
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:48 PM]
Agree on EMusk cutting like crazy.But who knows, he might be right somehow.
G, [18/2/2025 7:48 PM]
Why do you say he anyhow cut and cut blindly?
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:49 PM]
Nothing is perfect. That's why I disagree on your previous statement.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:49 PM]
Well ironically, I am quite an open person and willing to listen to good ideas.
But a general statement without specific will make me more intrusive.
Eg. Which one - whereby some bright people could come across something that hit the right spot.
W Goo, [18/2/2025 7:50 PM]
Well... Nice one π
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:50 PM]
Well, we will see what havoc he will cause.
The federal aviation safety is already showing its consequences.
Boeing without QC from federal staff - lead to inferior parts that cause Boeing to produce planes that have many faulty parts from Trump's 1st term.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:51 PM]
But I still didn't get the right answer that convince me to cut a government agency.
Local, [18/2/2025 7:52 PM]
Cremation method by burning millions of dead pet causes harmful to the environment. Gov can consider ban all pet farms and import pet, there are many other humane ways to make money
Kai Bin, [18/2/2025 7:52 PM]
Hi, they predict that they will hold the GE in either April or May.
G, [18/2/2025 7:53 PM]
Why u only mention stat board?
Why no mention of expensive programs?
Like why is MOH still stocking covid jabs?
Those are expensive to buy (because of how pharma price their products according to country's wealth). And for the Pfizer jabs, very expensive to store because of ultra low temperature storage requirements (-70°C)
Gabriel, [18/2/2025 7:54 PM]
Well, you did not answer the question about optimization also
G, [18/2/2025 7:55 PM]
Why need to create more stat boards?
Each stat board has at least a CEO level job and pay grade.. and lots of overheads to get their operations going..
Why can't the operations be subsumed under existing stat boards?
Derek Teo, [18/2/2025 7:56 PM]
Cut People’s Association (PA). PA serves a purpose during the early years of Singapore. The purpose seems to be diluted; at least I don’t feel the presence of a sense of what they are trying to achieve. Also, PA purpose and business model is slow to commensurate the ever changing demographics of Singaporean.
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:56 PM]
So any good suggestions to restructure the statutory boards?
And still maintain Singapore as the top civil service in the World?
G, [18/2/2025 7:57 PM]
Like MOH's latest new stat board.. it's a stat board for crises.
Are we expecting regular ongoing crisis that need a CEO to always be there?
Why not remain as task force to only be stood up when required?
Why need to continue paying CEO (and c-suitr) salary and bonuses?
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 7:59 PM]
Wow.
Hopefully Singapore still can survive...
G, [18/2/2025 7:59 PM]
We survived without one in sars, mers, and covid. You are being pessimistic
LCL (Danny εΏ), [18/2/2025 8:00 PM]
I trust the current government and civil service....
Thank you.
And will continue to vote for them
REACH Singapore, [18/2/2025 8:00 PM]
Dear Contributors
We will be closing the chat for today.
Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.
Goodnight!
Megan π
Gabriel, [18/2/2025 8:01 PM]
But I still didn't get the right answer that convince me that the govt has optimized their spending.
====
1. It is interesting and important to revisit previous Budget comments which unfortunately are limited by time for in-depth discussion - ie. Someone raise a question is there a better way to control the budget such as cutting government spendings in 3 ways. They are - is spending optimal in government, needs to cut agencies, cut program deem expensive.
2. I think these are valid comments and deserve to examine them carefully because it go right into the heart of an effective and efficient governance - which make us the top ranking civil service in the World and cannot be trivial with.
3. In fact, an effective government make Singapore competitive and safeguard the lives and livelihood of Singaporeans and deserve special scrutiny.
4. Let's address the issue one by one head-on.
a. Is our civil service optimally staff or overstaff vis a vis its performance.
Let us look at PSD empirical study on the staffing of civil service and public office versus outcomes.
Follow by global report on the performance ranking of Singapore Civil Service that is rank top in the World in terms of performance and staffing.
The same conclusion is reported by New York Times.
Thomas Friedman of The New York Times considers the Singapore Civil Service to be one of the most efficient and uncorrupt bureaucracies in the world, with a high standard of discipline and accountability.
It is also considered a key contributor to the success of Singapore since its independence.
Compared to most other countries, Singapore has a relatively small number of civil servants per capita, with its civil service considered highly efficient and ranked among the best globally, largely due to its smaller size and focus on meritocracy; as of 2022, Singapore's civil service employs around 87,000 people, significantly lower than many other nations with larger populations.
Key points about Singapore's civil service:
Small size:
Singapore's civil service is considered small relative to its population, contributing to its perceived efficiency.
High ranking:
Studies often place Singapore's civil service at the top of global rankings for performance and effectiveness.
Public Service vs. Civil Service:
The "Singapore Public Service" encompasses a wider group including statutory boards, while the "Civil Service" refers specifically to government ministries.
Frequently Asked Questions
https://www.psd.gov.sg/faq/#:~:text=ABOUT%20THE%20SINGAPORE%20PUBLIC%20SERVICE&text=The%20Singapore%20Public%20Service%20employs,access%20their%20websites%20for%20details.
Is Singapore Civil service the most optimally staff ?
The Singapore Civil Service is indeed known for its efficiency and effectiveness. Here are some reasons why:
Organizational Structure
1. *Flat hierarchy*: The civil service has a relatively flat organizational structure, which facilitates quick decision-making and communication.
2. *Clear roles and responsibilities*: Each ministry and department has well-defined roles and responsibilities, minimizing overlap and confusion.
Human Resource Management
1. *Merit-based recruitment*: The civil service recruits based on merit, ensuring that the best candidates are selected for each role.
2. *Comprehensive training and development*: Officers receive regular training and development opportunities to enhance their skills and knowledge.
3. *Performance-based evaluations*: Officers are evaluated based on their performance, ensuring that those who excel are recognized and rewarded.
Productivity and Efficiency
1. *Streamlined processes*: The civil service has implemented various initiatives to streamline processes, reduce bureaucracy, and increase productivity.
2. *Leveraging technology*: The government has invested heavily in technology to improve efficiency, transparency, and citizen engagement.
3. *Data-driven decision-making*: The civil service uses data analytics to inform policy decisions, ensuring that resources are allocated effectively.
Talent Attraction and Retention
1. *Competitive salaries and benefits*: The civil service offers competitive salaries and benefits to attract and retain top talent.
2. *Opportunities for growth and development*: Officers have access to various career development opportunities, including scholarships and fellowships.
3. *Positive work culture*: The civil service fosters a positive work culture that values teamwork, innovation, and work-life balance.
While there's always room for improvement, the Singapore Civil Service is widely regarded as one of the most efficient and effective in the world.
Singapore tops global civil service ranking
https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/singapore-tops-global-civil-service-ranking/
The Singapore Civil Service is the bureaucracy of civil servants that supports the Government of Singapore. Along with the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF), statutory boards, and other independent government bodies, the civil service makes up the overall public service of Singapore.[1] As of 2022, the civil service has about 87,000 employees.[2]
Thomas Friedman of The New York Times considers the Singapore Civil Service to be one of the most efficient and uncorrupt bureaucracies in the world, with a high standard of discipline and accountability.[3] It is also considered a key contributor to the success of Singapore since its independence
Singapore Civil Service - Wikipedia
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore_Civil_Service
b. Should we remove some statutory boards or government agencies to cut cost and government spendings.
1 suggestion is to cut PA mentioning that PA has out run its usefulness that didn't take into account the changing demographics.
Well my personal experience tell me that myself, my extended families and close friends still take part in many programs organised by PA, in their various CCs and enjoying the benefits of it.
Eg. Calligraphy, learning taichi, previously booking badminton courts, previously study rooms to study during exam times, swimming pool for swimming, Singpass resets, haircuts, cooking lessons and so many activities such as digital ambassadors teaching elderly to use smartphones, play basketball, converting into covid vaccination centres (I took my 3 jabs there), students activities organised in CCs etc.
My relative even volunteer as digital ambassador to help the elderly auntie and uncle.
Also learn cooking from them.
Some of my neighbours are also regular patronage of CC.
In fact, one coffeeshop stall owners donate the entire earnings from her stall to the CCs on her last day of business to sponsor CC activities to benefit elderly folks when the coffeeshop close and switch owners before retiring.
Yesterday I happen to walk past the CC and see many elderly sitting and socialising.
In fact, the CCs are heavily patronized by elderly, young, middle aged from all demographics.
Cannot imagine cutting PA...
I think the backlash will be horrendous - based on the patronage of different walks of people visiting CCs for various activities everyday.
I am one of the regular CC patron.
The People's Association (PA) is a statutory board in Singapore that plays a vital role in building and bridging communities. Here are some of the key functions of the PA:
Community Engagement
1. *Grassroots Engagement*: PA works closely with grassroots organizations, community centers, and residents' committees to engage citizens and promote community bonding.
2. *Community Programs*: PA organizes various community programs, such as cultural events, sports activities, and educational workshops, to foster social cohesion and community spirit.
Community Development
1. *Community Centre Management*: PA manages a network of community centers, which serve as hubs for community activities, programs, and services.
2. *Community Development Projects*: PA initiates and supports community development projects, such as upgrading of community facilities, to improve the quality of life for residents.
Social Cohesion
1. *Racial Harmony*: PA promotes racial harmony and understanding through various initiatives, such as cultural events and dialogues.
2. *Social Inclusion*: PA works to promote social inclusion and support vulnerable groups, such as low-income families, seniors, and people with disabilities.
Partnership and Collaboration
1. *Partnerships with Community Groups*: PA partners with community groups, voluntary welfare organizations, and other stakeholders to leverage resources and expertise.
2. *Collaboration with Government Agencies*: PA works closely with government agencies to ensure that community needs are addressed and policies are implemented effectively.
By fulfilling these functions, the PA plays a crucial role in building a harmonious and cohesive society in Singapore.
c. Cutting some programs eg. Covid vaccination?
(Majority of Singapore population 81% get covid vaccination and save our lives)
Cut Emergency crisis health program - to preempt Disease X.
I think I trust the Minister of Health - to have vision and foresight that have saved the population lives during covid.
Proven and tested!
Thank you very much.
I think I can trust my life with the Minister of Health come Disease X.
π
And to mention we survive during sars, mers, covid - magically.
People didn't know how much works are done behind the scene during SARs to work out policies and workflow to segregate staff, VCs, 1st time Parliament conducted through video conferencing using ISDN and many civil service supporting Ministers and top civil servants electronically to get the government and civil service go on smoothly. Thermal imaging was 1st introduced to screen passengers in airport, ports and checkpoints.
And the broad framework for Sars protection was brought over to covid - that need to further restructure and fine tune because the nature of covid is quite different from SARS and is more infectious.
Community Centres (CCs) in Singapore are run by the People's Association (PA); the PA manages and oversees all CCs through Community Centre Management Committees (CCMCs) which are part of their network of grassroots organisations.
Key points about CCs and PA:
Management: The PA manages CCs through the CCMC structure.
Function: CCs serve as community spaces for people to interact and participate in various activities organised by the PA.
History: When the PA was established in 1960, it took over the existing community centres from the colonial government.
Community Club Management Committees
https://www.pa.gov.sg/our-network/grassroots-organisations/community-club-management-committees/#:~:text=What%20role%20does%20the%20CCMCs,for%20residents%20in%20the%20community.
February 17, 2025: Delta Air Lines plane crashes in Toronto, Canada | CNN.
The incident comes less than three weeks after an American Airlines plane collided midair with a US Army Black Hawk helicopter while on approach to Washington DC’s Reagan National Airport, and on the heels of deadly Jeju Air and Azerbaijan Airlines accidents in December.
https://edition.cnn.com/world/live-news/delta-plane-crash-toronto-flips-02-17-25/index.html
5th airline crash in a row after Trump takeover and Elon Musk fire many federal government staff on aviation safety in just 1 month plus in office.
This break the record of US aviation safety.
Since 2002 to 2024, no serious aviation crashes.
In 2025 after Trump take office, 5 serious aviation crashes within a month.
Mass firing of federal staff backfire.
1. To conclude, I believe the PM and Finance Minister will do a better job than me to explain and justify the government spendings in Parliament.
2. Not to forget that despite spending a big $143 billion (hear from CNA news) to benefit the population, Government still maintain a budget surplus of $6.8 billion.
That means Singapore government is very prudent in spendings and yet still maintain a healthy surplus. (not frivolous spendings to incur big debts running into trillion $ that need reckless drastic cuts by subsequent administration).
In fact year after year, the Government strive to maintain a balanced budget (not incurring any debts) and have successfully done so except in crisis years such as covid or global financial crisis.
3. In view of the very uncertain geopolitical landscape that is dynamically changing, the surplus will be a good reserve to tap on if suddenly the global political and economic landscape turn nasty.
‘It’s embarrassing’: Indonesia’s civil servants bemoan lack of toilet paper, drinking water as Prabowo’s budget cuts bite - CNA.
Civil servants said the belt-tightening measures have dented staff morale and could hurt the public.
It backfire on the public.
Imagine if those programs get defunded. The impact extends beyond civil servants — it affects the public who rely on these services,” she said.
Some public service providers have backtracked on their budget efficiency and cost cutting plans after public backlash.
CELIOS predicts that Indonesia’s economy will grow by only 4.7 per cent in 2025 due to these budget efficiency measures, below the 5.2 per cent targeted by the government.
Poorly executed policies could backfire politically, Agung added.
https://www.channelnewsasia.com/asia/indonesia-prabowo-budget-cuts-government-ministries-toilet-paper-water-lights-4943966
No comments:
Post a Comment