Wednesday, January 14, 2026

REACH (Telegram) 114 -  What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

(SK)

14 Jan 2026 (10am - 7pm)


REACH (Telegram)

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 10:00 am]

Dear Contributors,

Welcome Back! 😊

⏰ We will be opening the chat from 10.15am to 9pm today. ⏰

House Rules (short version of our Terms of Use) to keep in mind:

1. Be kind and respectful. We all want to be in a safe space to share our views. 

2. Any and all threatening, abusive, vulgar or racially, religiously and ethnically objectionable content is prohibited. 

3. Consider the quiet ones among us and give them a chance to comment. 

4. No need to repeat your comment or in different forms (including caps) - we heard you loud and clear the first time. 

5. Let's protect each other's privacy and keep contact details in this group what it should always be - confidential. 

Full set of Terms of Use: https://www.reach.gov.sg/Participate/reach-telegram-group/REACH-Telegram-Group-Chat-Terms-of-Use/

We will strive to uphold these rules to ensure this is a safe space for all. 

Please be assured that the points made by participants during the chat are aggregated and shared with relevant agencies. 

The topic will be posted shortly. 

Thank you. 

Megan 😊

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 10:15 am]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

Parliament will sit today (14 Jan) at 12.30pm. Parliamentary questions will cover housing and transport issues, and support for the workforce. The Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill will continue to be discussed, and there will be a Motion on the conduct of Pritam Singh and consideration of his suitability to continue as the Leader of the Opposition.

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

πŸ“Œ Housing and Maintenance

Several questions were filed on housing matters. MPs raised concerns about everyday liveability in Housing & Development Board (HDB) estates, including satisfaction levels with cleanliness and noise levels.

Several questions focused on safety and infrastructure, including fire escape routes in corner units, the parking and charging of personal mobility devices (PMD) and personal mobility aids (PMA) after recent fire incidents.

Questions were also filed on support for seniors living alone, the Home Improvement Programme voting framework, and vacancies in HDB rental flats, and how housing policies can balance liveability, safety and inclusivity as estates age.

πŸ“Œ Support for Workforce

Questions were filed on support for the workforce.

MPs asked questions about regulating owners of large rental car fleets, and how they work with tripartite partners to safeguard drivers’ livelihoods, and results achieved from the Support for Job Redesign programme. 

The Job Redesign Centre of Excellence by Workforce Singapore (WSG) and Institute for Human Resource Professionals (IHRP) was launched in November 2025, and it serves as a one-stop touchpoint providing industry-relevant expertise and resources for enterprises to transform their business and workforce through job redesign.

πŸ“Œ Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill

The Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill will continue to be discussed on the roles and functions of SportSG to better support Singaporeans’ diverse sporting aspirations.

The Bill reflects how sports in Singapore have evolved over the last decade and the need to continue to evolve to serve not just medal ambitions but also Singapore’s people, its social compact, and its national identity. The Bill also advances formal recognition of areas such as disability sports and e-sports to reflect how the scene has evolved locally and globally. 

πŸ“Œ Notice of Motion on Mr Pritam Singh

The Motion on the conduct of Pritam Singh and consideration of his suitability to continue as the Leader of the Opposition will be discussed. 

πŸ“Œ Other Issues

Other parliamentary questions include regulating pet businesses, how Singapore builds on its established working relationship with the Saudi authorities in managing Hajj arrangements, Singapore’s food security and pollution concerns, support for caregivers, support for the homeless, food options at hawker centres and food safety.

πŸ‘‰ https://www.parliament.gov.sg/docs/default-source/order-paper/order-paper---14jan2026.pdf 

πŸ‘‰  https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/fire-safety-measures-government-stiffer-actions-pmds-amds-goh-pei-ming-5322321 

πŸ‘‰  https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/housing/hip-voting-process-to-be-studied-after-2-tiong-bahru-blocks-fail-to-meet-threshold-chee-hong-tat 

πŸ‘‰  https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/transport/companies-barred-from-selling-private-hire-cars-to-individuals-for-3-years-after-registration 

πŸ‘‰  https://www.straitstimes.com/business/new-one-stop-resource-portal-to-guide-s-pore-employers-on-redesigning-jobs-amid-disruption-competition 

πŸ‘‰  https://www.mccy.gov.sg/about-us/news-and-resources/second-reading-of-the-singapore-sports-council-ssc-amendment-bill/

πŸ‘‰  https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/parliament-to-debate-pritams-suitability-as-leader-of-the-opposition-after-conviction-for-lying

----


REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 11:00 am]

[ Poll : Which issue(s) are you most interested in for today's Parliament sitting? Share your reasons in the chat! (You may choose more than one option.)

 ]

- Housing and Maintenance

- Support for Workforce

- Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill

- Motion on Pritam Singh

- Others (Please share your views in the chat below)

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 11:01 am]

Dear Contributors,

Please take a moment to participate in our polls and share your opinion. The poll questions are pinned for easy reference! You can choose more than one option and your vote is anonymous. 

We look forward to hearing your thoughts on today’s topic!

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

Thank you.

Megan

365, [14/1/2026 11:15 am]

I'm pro-gov for majority of the time, but this motion on Pritam is too much already. It should've been settled and moved on after his court case was settled.

365, [14/1/2026 11:18 am]

Maybe they can discuss on more stringent consequences for any of the mps if they were to be found guilty of such cases in future, but not harping on this case itself

Andy, [14/1/2026 11:18 am]

Yeah we're all tired of it

Daniel, [14/1/2026 11:33 am]

Feels like at this point this should be something that WP handles internally. (Given that is has been handled in court and all).

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 11:36 am]

Pap like opponent got mistake then straight away want to use the mistake to kill

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 11:36 am]

Like war in parliament

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [14/1/2026 11:41 am]

PMDs n mobility devices should be treat like cars n bikes. 

Should have proper parking space down the blk

N charging ports.

Those selling PMDs n mobility devices should have proper licenses same as cars n motorbikes.

Same like cars n bikes need to go regular checkups, buy insurance should apply to PMDs n mobility devices

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [14/1/2026 11:41 am]

All should have licence plate

365, [14/1/2026 11:44 am]

Anything mobility device that has more than just your limbs powering it should have proper license and registration

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [14/1/2026 11:46 am]

HDB mp's should do mthly walks around estate. To inspect themselves to see condition.

RY, [14/1/2026 11:47 am]

Already proven Pritman has mis-conduct as MP or even as lawyer, he no longer damn suitable to rep as head of any political party, or even as MP in parliament

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [14/1/2026 11:47 am]

HDBs should be made more sound proof. 

My area very quite hardly sound pollution.  Except road drillings

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [14/1/2026 11:49 am]

Gov both parties should work together.  Make sg better. Fight among ourselves no gd

RY, [14/1/2026 12:16 pm]

I hope more financial support can be to caregivers, since this grp unlikely to work full time for a living, due to family commitment 

Most time, family member do not give any financial compensation to another family member, whom take up the caregiver role, since they think he/she also family and should take up the responsibility

So far, Ntuc started the UCare for Caregiver last year with $200 fund

Ntuc also started the UCare for special needs school-going child last year after Budget announcement

But what abt Special Needs Adult that family still has to continue to look after upon their adulthood ?

Most time this grp of Special Needs Adult, they dont have the earning capacity when they grow up later, but family still have to take care of them upon their adulthood till they demised 

Caregivers role not only limited to elderly at home, but also to those family with special needs/handicapped children/siblings

AIC (govt) only comes in when this grp (elderly/handicapped) have mobility issues (unable to function 3 of the 6)  

It is not only when this grp has mobility problem then family has to look after, even when they are mobile, family still have to look after them

Seems govt not giving much support to caregivers (unable to work), bec have to take care of special needs adults/siblings and elderly at home

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 12:30 pm]

Dear contributors,

Parliament sitting is now live.

Catch the livestream of today's Parliament sitting here: 

https://www.youtube.com/live/yig-Ca7BDoQ?si=4W5KRVcUv1wYOx7w

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:19 pm]

I just saw a pmd man aggressively reversed at a lift lobby. He wanted to get to the lift at the other door. A woman had to dodge out of her way. The pmd can accelerate quite fast and is pretty big

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:20 pm]

I think regulation should not only be on speed but also on size. Pmd shouldnt be big cargo scooter but merely an electric wheelchair

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:21 pm]

In term of regulation, the gov should impose limit on the engine so people dont use it as a personal cargo truck

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:22 pm]

Limit the size too so it doesnt take more than an ordinary wheelchair

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:24 pm]

In a normal and electric wheelchair the feet and head are pretty exposed from collisions, especially from front. This makes user very cautious

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:24 pm]

Pmds these days are literal scooters. Bang the wall from front and the wheel take the hit, feet protected and body safe

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:26 pm]

They are so rugged its like the manufacturer assumes the user will ram into things

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:26 pm]

Idk if these people think they have the right of way, or assume people will dodge them

Nicholas, [14/1/2026 1:27 pm]

So many fires in recent times in HDBs and Condos linked to PMDs, there should be some stringent standards required of the battery pack and maintenance so that it won't suddenly explode or catch fire.

Adam, [14/1/2026 1:30 pm]

Funny thing is, the pmd kinda treats its existence as a hazard like a truck. It has rear light and make a loud beep when it was reversing.

I think pmd should be allowed but these days the manufacturers are pushing to the limit on what the gov will let slip. Need to regulate with a strong arm. Why is gov so weak? What will pap of old do to these users and seller who act in bad faith

G, [14/1/2026 1:40 pm]

This unhealthy fixation with Pritam is too much. But then again, this is in line what LHL said many moons ago:

"But supposing you had a Parliament with 10, 15, 20 opposition members out of 80.

“Then, instead of spending my time thinking of what is the right policy for Singapore, I’m going to spend all my time – I have to spend all my time – thinking what is the right way to fix them, what is the right way to buy own my supporters over, how can I solve this week’s problem and forget about next year’s challenges?”"

So fixing Pritam instead of addressing cost of living issues, even putting in place policies like that 10¢ per drink packaging that will cause drink prices to balloon up to 60¢ more (according to https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/beverage-container-return-scheme-fees-drink-prices-importers-5854696)

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 2:01 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 2:19 pm]

Dear Contributors, 

To keep up to date on Parliamentary proceedings, you may also refer to the live blog by the Straits Times! 😊

https://www.straitstimes.com/live-singapore-parliament-jan-2026


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:20 pm]

1. In corporate, if any management or staff lies, or conspire with others to lie, it is a disciplinary case and will be fired.


2. In schools, if student is dishonest, plagiarism, lie in an exam such as copying or research or study, it will be a disciplinary case, and the student will fail his subject and a black mark to his/her conduct record.


3. In court under oath, if lie in court, is a penal code offence. 

In Singapore, lying under oath (perjury) is a serious offense under Section 193 of the Penal Code (https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=https://sso.agc.gov.sg/Act/PC1871?ProvIds%3Dpr193-&ved=2ahUKEwjMnuCpiP6RAxVXS2cHHfmlD3QQy_kOegQIARAB&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw14is5gzz2C9FOqRfBDwSiZ&ust=1768034613030000) and carries a penalty of imprisonment for up to 7 years, and/or a fine, as it undermines the administration of justice. The specific sentence depends on the facts of the case, but it's treated as a grave offense, distinct from giving false information to public servants. 


4. What is more the lie, and the conspiracy in the leadership team to lie under oath in a Parliament, the highest office, whereby lawmakers are elected to be the representatives of the voters?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:22 pm]

Trump absolutely has no restrain in whatever he wants to do.

Because he was given the absolute power by his voters and Supreme Court to act with impunity (to do something wrong, harmful, or illegal without fear of punishment or negative consequences. 

It implies that Trump believes he is, or is allowed to be, above the law or normal rules of accountability. ):-

1. His voters vote him in to be the President despite a long tail of legal charges against him and even successful convicted guilty of felony. Voters willingness to forgive his crimes have embolden him to be above the law and to act with impunity.


2. Supreme Court has presided that whatever illegality he do or law he breaks as President can be forgiven and pardon. This gives him the absolute power to set his own morality and act with impunity without regards to the law.


Hence the concept of pardon or forgiving sin with no legal or political consequences is a critical flaw concept and should not allow to take root in our political scene.


In fact it is very dangerous - as Trump impunity can virtually start a World War exploiting his powerful military whereby the check and balance within the US political system is unable to rein him in or ineffective as Trump practically run all the counter measures down.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:24 pm]

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/world/trump-morality-only-restraint-global-power-new-york-times-5847326

Trump says 'my own morality' is only restraint on global power.

The Republican president also said he does need to abide by international law, but added "it depends what your definition of international law is".

Trump is saying he got absolute impunity above all international law.

Yeah, there is one thing. My own morality. My own mind. It's the only thing that can stop me," Trump told the newspaper when asked if there were any limits on his global powers.


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:25 pm]

So you mean lying in this society is not okay but covering up the wrong doing of a junior is ok


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:26 pm]

Once a termite seeps in, the whole foundation crumpled.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:26 pm]

For example?


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:27 pm]

LHL covering up for tan chuan Jin for 2 yr


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:28 pm]

I know you are going to say this.

Let us look at the facts.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:28 pm]

SM Lee didn't make public Tan Chuan Jin and another MP affairs is because:-

1. He reprimanded both of them in private and demand they stop their affairs and give them opportunity to stop their wrong doing.


2. He want to give both of them space to repair their hurts to their family members by not making the affairs public so that their families can heal with less pain.


3. Private affairs are not crimes and does not affect their work.


4. SM Lee after giving them chances to make amend and right their wrongful deed discover they quietly resume the affair - then decided to make public the affairs and told them to step down.


5. SM Lee did not lie or attempt to hide wrongdoings. In fact, he provides opportunities for them to stop wrong and put things right.


6. But the moment SM Lee discover both didn't attempt to stop, he immediately make the affairs public. Even though private affairs are not crimes, he decided to asked both to step down.


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:32 pm]

But at the period of time he did not halt and demote his position when he notices it, instead still putting him in a important position

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:32 pm]

While pitam is worse asking raja to lie


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 2:33 pm]

When he did not halt, SM Lee make it public and ask them to step down.


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:33 pm]

But seriously the iswaran case or tjc case they deal it very fast

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:34 pm]

But pitam case is just too long

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 2:34 pm]

I think one election period is gone liao

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:02 pm]

Actually I think it's long because that's the legal/political process. I could be wrong. And I do think it's a fair question to ask, after all this, is Pritam still worthy to be LO. Personally I think still can la, I don't see anyone else as capable as Pritam for now in opp.

Although to us is like some long TVB series with all the reporting and recordings. Not really interested anymore

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 3:03 pm]

Ya not my taiji type of things

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:03 pm]

Ya lor.. 🀣


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:04 pm]

@Babe:Pritam Singh cross 4 red flags:-

1. He covertly encourages his MP to lie in Parliament to protect his party reputation.

His integrity as Opposition Leader is profoundly questionable.

Is this the political leader that Singapore want?

2. In election, he play the most dangerous cards - political identity specifically races and religions that will stoke various communities emotion and could possibly turn into violence just to win votes.

3. He make use of foreign media to air his grievances.

4. He promote the view that as long as he win election and get the support of the opposition voters - he can run with impunity without political and legal consequences - emulating what a Superpower leader is doing.

I think Singapore shall not tolerate such politics.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:04 pm]

Pritam Singh and Faisal Manap both cross the lines during election on playing with :-

1. Collaboration with foreign country radical Muslims to impose bumi special privileges at the expense of racial and religious equality and meritocracy - that will cause disharmony and tensions among our multi racial and ethnic communities in Singapore.

(The special privileges will make the bumi self-entitled, handicap, lazy and rely on others to finance them - a crutch mentality. Singapore should not breed such community into our society.)


2. Playing along the identity and racial lines triggering national security concerns.


3. Both lies and propagate lies in Parliament on Raesh Khan case.


WP if want to be a serious party should request both to step down from CEC and Pritam Singh should also step down as opposition leader in Parliament as this role has access to security briefings, OSA information and deal with emergency and crisis issues.

Hence WP must be wise to remove Pritam Singh and Faisal Manap that promote such mentality into Singapore. Dangerous for Singapore.


@Babe:Pritam Singh should step down as Opposition Leader and should not have access to National Security information.


Andy, [14/1/2026 3:05 pm]

Who is Babe...


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:05 pm]

Babe = Danny


Andy, [14/1/2026 3:06 pm]

πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 3:06 pm]

Ya I don't care if he is still a lo lol or just be a ordinary mp. I think nobody cares

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 3:07 pm]

Things will go as usual

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 3:08 pm]

As from what I remember lo only appointed for last 2 or 3 election period

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:09 pm]

Yeah I think the other topics, Housing, Workforce, Sports are much more relevant as they affect people directly


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:10 pm]

Low Thia Khiang and Chian See Tong are both honourable oppositions with statures.

In fact both can be the Opposition Leaders that work for the good of Singapore.


RY, [14/1/2026 3:10 pm]

I concur

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:11 pm]

I certainly don't think LTK was viewed that way when he was still in parliament

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:11 pm]

People get glorified only when they leave

RY, [14/1/2026 3:11 pm]

I concur too


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:11 pm]

He was.

LKY and lhl speak well on both of them.


Andy, [14/1/2026 3:12 pm]

He was outspoken, yes. Honourable.. hmm

Andy, [14/1/2026 3:12 pm]

People did speak well of Pritam too


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:14 pm]

LHL approach Low Thia Khiang to be leader opposition.

But he refused because at that time, the opposition number is still weak only Aljunied grc and Hougang.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 3:14 pm]

A long journey see the true colors of a person.


Andy, [14/1/2026 3:17 pm]

The journey may still have long left to go.

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 3:32 pm]

Leader of The House Ms Indranee Rajah raises a motion on whether Workers’ Party chief Pritam Singh should continue as Leader of the Opposition. 

Catch the livestream of today's Parliament sitting here:

https://www.youtube.com/live/yig-Ca7BDoQ?si=4W5KRVcUv1wYOx7w

You may also refer to the live blog by The Straits Times.

https://www.straitstimes.com/live-singapore-parliament-jan-2026


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:00 pm]

1. I have been reading the fires from PMD in HDB flats - usually very damaging, the whole flat interior got burned down and include fatalities and injuries.

2. Also see in the news that 70% are from non-certified safety PMDs.

3. Not sure out of the 30%, does certified safety PMDs also trigger fire within the HDB flats?

4. If yes, then charging PMDs inside a flat is very dangerous - because it endanger the occupants as well as the neighbours.

5. Baring the facts in 3 and 4, if certified PMDs also is a safety risk, then I support 1 participant suggestion to make charging PMDs along the car park vicinity like EV charging of cars.

6. However, if certified PMDs is not a safety risk - as facts bare itself out - then Point 5 can be temporary be put to rest - unless the same safety risk surface.


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 4:05 pm]

I do not own a pmd so idk how's it charges. But ya if it pose too much of a fire hazard, we need to look into the safety design of the vehicle

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 4:06 pm]

Cause charging along the carpark also cause a hazard to cars

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 4:07 pm]

If electric cars have no problem charging overnight I don't see why pmd could not achieve that safety standards


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:07 pm]

If pmd charging is like the new smartphone that come with charging protection software, that is when fully charge, will automatically cut off charging, then it is safe.

Because lithium batteries inherently when overcharge become unstable and will burn uncontrollably.


Daniel, [14/1/2026 4:07 pm]

Also not very practical for PWD who really need it to get around. Can't really ask them to walk down to the carpark.

Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 4:08 pm]

So the law must states safety specs clearly


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:09 pm]

But even if certified safe pmds after long duration, the safety mechanism fails, it could trigger a fire because it no longer able to cut off the charging when fully charged.

Hence long journey see the true colors of the pmds.

Only authority has access to such information.


Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 4:09 pm]

And maybe let the manufacturing to do warranty check or inspection service once every few years like car


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:10 pm]

My worry is people can steal the pmd unless can locked.

But for safety reasons, some inconvenience should be ok.

Eg. Bicycles also are parked downstairs.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:10 pm]

Hmm...

Good point.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:11 pm]

PMA yes is a problem - because they are elderly or disabled.

Yes good point.

PMA maybe can exempt.


365, [14/1/2026 4:45 pm]
I think there's already safety requirements written into our law already, issue is there's insufficient enforcement
365, [14/1/2026 4:45 pm]
A law is only as good as when it can be enforced
365, [14/1/2026 4:47 pm]
Step up street enforcement randomly every 1 or 2 weeks, impose heavier punishments, including impounding any non compliant device or when other rules are being flouted

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:47 pm]
Yes.
This is the problem with the safety of the pmds.
Because even there are laws, some people don't comply, neighbors and occupants are still put at risk.
If empirical facts reveal the even certified pmds also pose a risk from the 30% certified pmds, then erring on the safe side, government should consider charging at carpark vicinity.

365, [14/1/2026 4:48 pm]
Trace back the workshops that perform modifications and shut them if required
365, [14/1/2026 4:49 pm]
If you don't have enough manpower to consistently enforce it, then supplement with heavy punishment to deter such behavior
365, [14/1/2026 4:49 pm]
Low chance of getting caught + low consequence = low risk for offenders, simple risk matrix

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 4:50 pm]
Because open space at car park less risky compare to an enclosed spaces at home.

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 5:16 pm]
In case you missed it, here are some updates from the parliamentary proceedings so far:
- *On Housing and Maintenance:* https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/hdb-240-mould-complaints-neighbours-air-conditioners-5857756
- *On Animal Welfare for Animal-Related Businesses:* https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/animal-welfare-laws-review-will-consider-requirements-for-cctv-at-pet-groomers-alvin-tan
- *On Support for Caregivers:* https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/over-14600-caregivers-of-seniors-benefitted-from-subsidised-respite-care-services-in-2025-moh
- *On the Motion on Pritam Singh:* https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/pritam-has-shown-failure-of-leadership-failure-to-take-responsibility-indranee
Nicholas, [14/1/2026 5:41 pm]
Not good to keep harping on the Raeesah Khan lied and subsequently Pritam Singh lied topic, it's a distraction that is taking up precious time in parliament. Ongoing since year 2021, it's "flogging a dead horse". 
Need to move on and talk about things that are important to Singaporeans, how to help the country navigate the challenging global situation with Trump power moves etc.
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 5:42 pm]
Cause it's like decision is with pm so kind of waste time
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 5:43 pm]
Not like parliament have other party other than pap and wp
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 5:44 pm]
Just pap internal vote is enough
G, [14/1/2026 5:59 pm]
Does it even have to be put to a vote?
Doesn't the PM have authority to grant or remove the leader of opposition title?
If PM does have the authority to grant or remove, then why don't just make a decision and get on with it?
Why waste so much time debating on this.. for MPs to give 5¢ 10¢ comments and waste valuable parliament time?
G, [14/1/2026 5:59 pm]
Just make a decision and move on to more pressing issues
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:00 pm]
Ya lor
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:00 pm]
Why keep dragging
G, [14/1/2026 6:00 pm]
The longer this drags on, the more it looks like the PM is indecisive who hesitates to make decisions
REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 6:00 pm]
πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:01 pm]
I hope tdy session is the last episode of this sia
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:01 pm]
Tiring
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:01 pm]
Use this time to tackle cost of living is have better worth lor
Jun Ming, [14/1/2026 6:02 pm]
Like this motion can done it within a hour make it long winded
G, [14/1/2026 6:19 pm]
She seems to be enjoying being longwinded recounting history
Nicholas, [14/1/2026 6:21 pm]
The topic on recent fire incidents in residential buildings due to PMDs should be expanded to talk about fire safety in high-rise commercial buildings as well. During fire drills, I wonder what will happen in a real fire given escape stairways are narrow, there'll be a lot of smoke etc. The recent mega fire in the Hong Kong residential tower highlights the difficulties of escaping from a burning high-rise building.
μ—¬μžμΉœκ΅¬, μ²«μ‚¬λž‘ πŸ†, [14/1/2026 6:38 pm]
She's getting high at mocking pritam she smiled when she did so then the whole house laugh with her.

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 6:52 pm]
1. I am not sure if all HDB design layouts are the same.
2. Yes the stairways are a bit tight - can let 2 persons walk together only.
3. But I notice there are 2 pathway for my flat. 1 main door another back door.
4. If one pathway got fire or smoke, I can take another door using another pathway.
5. Also if a flat is on fire, the walls and doors are fire-rated - I think at least 2 hours.
6. So as long as the doors are closed, fire and little smoke can spread quickly outside. 
Fire become compartmentalised and cannot spread from flat to flat unlike the HK flats. 
(Note :- I witnessed in my neighboring block in which a flat is on fire due to PMD. It was burning for about 1/2 hour in the flat, people run out. 
But no neighbors flat catch the fire.
When the fire engine come, the firemen can quickly extinguish the fire).
7.. Residents got chance to run out safely.
8. That is why during HIP, I raise concern when both the doors are changed to non fire rated. I refuse to change and reuse my 2 old doors that are fire-rated.

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 8:06 pm]
1. Also noticed that during HIP, scaffolding are metal scalfolding not bamboo sticks scalfolding.
2. Also HIP don't use netting.
3. Hence the chances of catching fire and spreading through the net and bamboo stick does not happen like the HK flats.
4. However, I noticed for commercial sites building development, green netting are used - probably to catch falling debris and catch dust. But hopefully they are fire-retardant.
5. Having say so, I also hope that power cables running around the houses and building should also be fire-retardant and will not catch fire.

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/1/2026 8:19 pm]
1. Also another thing, the WSG initiative that help business and worker redesign business and jobs through the centralise redesign centre is a very good effort - to ensure that businesses can transform and restructure relevant to the industry needs and remain viable and sustainable.

2. As the centre is a centralised redesign centre, there will be pooled resources available, access to wide variety of ideas and exposure - and hence able to customise relevant, up-to-date business process, needs, skillsets and market information to help the business.

3. In addition, workers will also similarly benefits from such centralised resources.

4. Most important, the redesign centre should incorporate AI into the business and the workers' skillsets --- that will greatly bring about a leap and bound productivity jump.

5. I recently visited an eye clinic to check my eyes. In the previous few visits, the eyes nurse specialist that uses the eye machine to capture my eyeballs image needs to be operated by the nurse specialist on every angle of the eyeballs.

6. But this time I went, she just asked me to place my head and keep my eyes open, while she walked around to do other chores. 
The eye machine automatically captures every angle of my eyeballs and she doesn't need to intervene.
Then a naughty thought comes to my mind, I deliberately fool the machine by intermediately closing my eyes when it is about to capture my eyeballs image. But it is able to flag errors and keep taking the image until it gets a good image of every angle of my eyeballs.
Then the nurse without even looking at the machine say, ok completed already. (I guess the machine alerts her, when the images are satisfactorily captured).
Then I asked the nurse, how come this time the eye machine is automated, is it AI?
She laughed heartily, and said she can now concentrate on doing other jobs. Her productivity indeed increases by leaps and bounds.

REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 8:48 pm]
Dear Contributors,
⏰ We will be closing the chat in 10 minutes ⏰
Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.
Goodnight!
Megan 😊
REACH Singapore, [14/1/2026 9:00 pm]
Dear Contributors
We will be closing the chat for today.
Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.
Goodnight!
Megan 😊

====

Tuesday, January 13, 2026

REACH (Telegram) 113 -  What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

(SK)

13 Jan 2026 (10am - 7pm)


REACH (Telegram)

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 9:45 am]

Dear Contributors,

Welcome Back! 😊

⏰ We will be opening the chat from 10am to 9pm today. ⏰

House Rules (short version of our Terms of Use) to keep in mind:

1. Be kind and respectful. We all want to be in a safe space to share our views. 

2. Any and all threatening, abusive, vulgar or racially, religiously and ethnically objectionable content is prohibited. 

3. Consider the quiet ones among us and give them a chance to comment. 

4. No need to repeat your comment or in different forms (including caps) - we heard you loud and clear the first time. 

5. Let's protect each other's privacy and keep contact details in this group what it should always be - confidential. 

Full set of Terms of Use: https://www.reach.gov.sg/Participate/reach-telegram-group/REACH-Telegram-Group-Chat-Terms-of-Use/

We will strive to uphold these rules to ensure this is a safe space for all. 

Please be assured that the points made by participants during the chat are aggregated and shared with relevant agencies. 

The topic will be posted shortly. 

Thank you. 

Megan 😊

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 10:01 am]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

Parliament will sit today (13 Jan) at 12.00pm. Parliamentary questions will cover support for seniors through the Silver Support Scheme and the cross-border transport arrangements with Malaysia. Bills that will be discussed include the National Council of Social Service (Amendment) Bill and the Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill.

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

πŸ“Œ Silver Support Scheme & Senior Support

Seven MPs filed questions regarding support for lower-income seniors through the Silver Support Scheme.

The Silver Support Scheme provides quarterly cash payments to eligible seniors aged 65 and above who live in smaller HDB flats and have low household incomes.

Questions were asked on whether the current $1,500 monthly income threshold should be raised to align with the $1,600 Local Qualifying Salary for consistency across government schemes. Questions were also filed on extending eligibility to seniors in Executive Apartments and whether those above 80 in smaller HDB flats should automatically receive higher support, given they may have outlived life expectancy and depleted their CPF savings.

πŸ“Œ Cross-Border Transport

On Dec 5 2025, a joint announcement was made by Singapore and Malaysia that both countries would increase the quota from cross-border taxis from 200 each now to 500, and would allow taxis from either side to drop passengers off anywhere in their destination country. 

Questions were filed on measures to address these competitive pressures and support local drivers.

πŸ“Œ Bills to be debated in Parliament

Parliament will also debate two Bills. These include the National Council of Social Service (Amendment) Bill and the Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill.

The Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill seeks to update the roles and functions of Sport Singapore (SportSG) to better support Singaporeans' diverse sporting aspirations.

πŸ“Œ Other Issues

Other parliamentary questions include social media age restrictions following Australia's under-16 ban, sports funding and athlete recognition for SEA Games medallists, food security targets under the revised "30 by 30" initiative, and emergency preparedness including AED installation in new estates like Tengah.

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/additional-s10000-cash-bonus-among-changes-silver-housing-scheme-december-4975141

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.parliament.gov.sg/parliamentary-business/order-paper

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/spore-malaysia-to-increase-cross-border-taxi-quota-to-500-each-allow-passenger-drop-offs-anywhere

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/singapore-sports-council-bill-mccy-mind-sports-esports-5443961

----


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 10:53 am]

All healthcare providers in Singapore will be required to share patients’ key health data with a central system under a new law passed in parliament, with the changes taking effect from early next year.

Here's how it will work and what will be shared: https://cna.asia/3NiEh7O

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 10:54 am]

I wonder TCM under this

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 11:00 am]

[ Poll : Which issue(s) are you most interested in for today's Parliament sitting? Share your reasons in the chat! (You may choose more than one option.)S ]

- Silver Support Scheme

- Cross-border transport

- Social media age restrictions for minors 

- Sports funding and athlete recognition

- Food security and sustainability targets

- The National Council of Social Service (Amendment) Bill

- Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill

- Others (please share your views in the chats below)

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 11:02 am]

Dear Contributors,

Please take a moment to participate in our polls and share your opinion. 

The poll questions are pinned for easy reference! You can choose more than one option and your vote is anonymous. 

We look forward to hearing your thoughts on today’s topic!

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

Thank you.

Megan

365, [13/1/2026 11:35 am]

Regarding the social media age restrictions, I'm more curious on how they intend to implement it if it passes, will it affect everyone else?

We have a reference from the UK and AU, it really seems like doing for the sake of doing, inconveniencing everyone else without achieving anything as vpn is already a very well known and low effort way to bypass.

G, [13/1/2026 11:41 am]

What about political appointment holder salary review?

https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/committee-formed-to-review-salaries-for-political-appointment-holders-chan-chun-sing

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 11:43 am]

Silver support should not be given to those living in smaller flats. Should look into their retirement funds n income. Many those who are living in 4 n 5 rm. Are old timers. They r not going to sell at older age n buy smaller flats. All the coat of buying new flats r much higher.  Some have already paid finish for their 4 n 5 rm. They r old. Living alone. No savings. No income. Some 3rm flat owners own business r rich. Do background check

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 11:46 am]

Cross boarder. Should have limited taxi. And controlled price. Too many no one will take busses anymore. Trying to cut down traffic n cars. Increase clean  busses. Plus no standing. Wider seats can put their shopping bags with them.

Ethan, [13/1/2026 11:46 am]

Should ban social media for kids under the age of 16

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 11:47 am]

Sg should grow their own food. In school they should teach children basic home growing technical of certain veggies

Kai Bin, [13/1/2026 11:49 am]

Agreed

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 11:50 am]

Off topic. Think we should train our kids to be tough. Army training PE time for both girls n boys. SG is small everyone need to be ready to protect their country.

RY, [13/1/2026 11:52 am]

Hope the senior silver support (SSS) scheme may extend to larger HDB flat 

Seniors own larger HDB flat eg 5Rm, doesnt mean they paid for the mortgage loan and richer 

As many single unmarried children may joint name with parents and buy Hdb flat, but the children paid the mortgage loan ultimately 

Just feel that SSS shouldnt use small/big Hdb flat and owner as one of the criteria 

It will be more fairer to base on household income as the criteria and not how big/small the senior own  

Staying/owning larger Hdb flat, doesnt mean it is the senior is richer also

Bec by the age of 65 and above, many chronic illness maybe part of life, since most seniors unable to work as they aged further

And SSS will certainly help the seniors in daily expenses, similar to Cdc vouchers

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 11:53 am]

HP parent control should be able to lock the hp. So cannot download any app. If they hack the system. Parent should receive notifications


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 11:57 am]

1. I think important to ensure fire rated doors are used even for HIP programme.

2. Notice that in HIP, main door and side door don't use fire rated doors.

As a result, I refuse to change but reuse the old fire rated doors.


REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 12:01 pm]

Dear Contributors,

Parliament sitting is now live.

Catch the livestream of today's Parliament sitting here: 

https://www.youtube.com/live/eJFwFvujN0k?si=32ZUVukuGDCxR1g5

RY, [13/1/2026 12:04 pm]

I concur that kids nowsaday are spending too much on screen-time/HP, and miss the outdoor and precious childhood time

That is not gd for any growing up kids, whom just spending time on phone/social media

Further they are not matured enough to determine what is suitable for them to watch in social media eg RA

As many videos may brainwash or teach the kids the wrong life values eg AI chat leading to some suicide cases

This group of kids are labelled as "strawberry generation", whom unable to take much stress in life, since they nvr go thru much hardship since born

Many studies already show that too much screen-time is not gd to the kids growing up stage eg character-shaping, as they shd be engaged in more outdoor activities and balance both indoor/outdoor, just like school-life balance

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 12:06 pm]

Here i think government system need to work together.  There r too many agencies.  All playing passing the parcel game.

 E.g hdb blk I see fallen, cut trees. Dead leaves, rubbish at Npark n carparks. When u call town council, they say this is under this. That is under someone else.

 Tampines I see 4 different cleaners, 1 under each blk. Park is 1m from the blk, yet is so dirty. I see 1 cleaner only cleaning lift area landing for the overhead bridge. Why do we need individual cleaners for every block? Where is there no cleaner sweeping the park area. They can sweep n put the dead leaves in a bag. Sweep the sand away from walking area. 

Even lift landing are dirty. But when MPs come for rounding,  everything is cleared n washed. Why

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 12:08 pm]

Exercise park machines broken for mths. Not repaired


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 12:09 pm]

Report via OneService apps.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 12:10 pm]

The OneService app is Singapore's official platform for residents to report neighbourhood issues like cleanliness, illegal parking, or faulty facilities, connecting them directly with relevant agencies for quicker resolution; it also offers features to find parking, pay street parking, and even get alerts for local events, all managed through the app or its Kaki chatbot on WhatsApp/Telegram, simplifying citizen engagement with municipal services. 

Key Features:

Report Issues: Submit cases for HDB estates, roads, pests, cleanliness, illegal parking, and more.

Smart Routing: Automatically directs your feedback to the correct agency (Town Council, HDB, etc.).

Parking Services: Find parking lots, pay for street parking, and view past sessions.

Community Alerts: Get updates on local happenings and community projects.

Help Neighbour: Report neighbours in need (non-emergency situations) for social assistance.

Kaki Chatbot (https://www.google.com/search?hl=en-SG&ram_mb=7608&aos=20&ampcct=7499&qsubts=1768277412747&cs=0&q=Kaki+Chatbot&agsai=sz9tt_4yaSs&padt=118&gs_lp=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_iAwQIWhgBsAQAuAQAwgQA0AQAggUGCAAQACgA8QUlufGqdJ9LjYAGAZIHAzBqN5gHAaAH5-ED&rdid=6da625a6-6510-4d60-b9e1-937db0de20ad&client=ms-android-vivo-rvo3&source=and.gsa.widget.text&pf=i&mstk=AUtExfAjGNrH8I_efVadpRUb8LhidtMNOBy5kmjj0lhaiamp2cVu2pn-jeIS365Vpv2vq7lfcmmX5IG7A6y4bbflF930KSXtvPJ3BFuW7ZzgxuKD8Yl4JFoN_a3NrWuhNcSE3hKZZU2fTuMsUW2mKHsJ6QH4bjLlwjTfalo3YXjHkGJsp4g&csui=3&ved=2ahUKEwj0iPrY0oeSAxVCb2wGHdfTOKEQgK4QegQIAxAG): Access services via WhatsApp, Telegram, and Instagram for convenience. 

How it Works:

Download: Get the app from the App Store (https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=https://apps.apple.com/sg/app/oneservice-serving-your-estate/id947274394&ved=2ahUKEwj0iPrY0oeSAxVCb2wGHdfTOKEQy_kOegQIBRAB&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw2CaYsQzShJjDGj-Lpbmbx2&ust=1768363813889000) (iOS) or Google Play Store (Android).

Report: Select the issue type, add details (like photos), and submit.

Track: Receive updates as the relevant agency works on your case. 

Who's Behind It:

Developed by the Municipal Services Office (MSO) under Singapore's Ministry of National Development (https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.mnd.gov.sg/api/media/b7992fcd-cd47-46bd-8870-610ff70823e2&ved=2ahUKEwj0iPrY0oeSAxVCb2wGHdfTOKEQy_kOegQIBxAB&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw2CaYsQzShJjDGj-Lpbmbx2&ust=1768363813889000). 

OneService

29 Nov 2025 — The OneService app is a way to submit cases to OneService channels. You can use the app to: * Submit cases for problems in your estate * Submit feedb...

www.oneservice.gov.sg


RY, [13/1/2026 12:12 pm]

I also agree that more financial support shd be given to SG athetes

As it is not easy to tackle study/work together with full training

Since they maybe representing SG to participate in regional/intl events

However, they must still earn for their livelihood, since they are not full time salary paid by the govt, while they are training 

If I am correct, they are only rewarded with lumpsum, when they won in the regional/intl atheletes events eg Olympic


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 12:17 pm]

1. Also interested in ensuring food security.

2. Geopolitical climate getting very challenging.

3. Food security become critical in case during crisis, import foods become disrupted.


Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 12:17 pm]

πŸ‘

365, [13/1/2026 12:23 pm]

Cross border taxis need to provide better service, matching at least that of the illegal providers.

Illegal providers can arrange anywhere, anytime (even midnight, with surcharge), can go further distances in a single vehicle. Usually offer much more comfortable ride, with drivers gladly helping out with loading and offloading luggages.

Even if both were to cost the same (which the illegal ones are already increasing price quite a bit), it's a no brainer which one currently offers the better service.

Ginie/Komal ZENDORA J, [13/1/2026 12:23 pm]

Thk u for sharing

RY, [13/1/2026 12:23 pm]

SG govt shd be encouraging children to look after parents as they aged

If they (2 or 3 generation) stay together in 5rm or larger Hdb flat, means the seniors not eligible for SSS ?  

Seems that SSS is encouraging seniors to downsize their Hdb flat, in order to entitle to SSS .....


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 12:38 pm]

Feel that the MPs and town council should send brochures to all residents to download and make use of OneService apps to report any problems and issues that require town council service.

If possible, paste big posters in lift landing lobby to urge all residents to download OneService apps to report issues that require town council service.

This will reduce residents frustration as residents unaware of this service will call town council telephone number directly in which there is no means to track reported issue - resulting in no proper closure.

OneService apps will link multiple agencies or refer cases to the right agencies that supply the services.

Else residents will just call the town council telephone which usually is not a hotline and don't link cross agencies results in resident frustration.

OneService apps is easy to use, properly categorised and link the appropriate right agencies and reduce residents frustration.

Just submit a case attached with photos of the problem, agencies will respond - no additional stress or fuss from reportant.

And most of the time, issues will be resolved within the service level - OneService apps track its progress, its completion date and service satisfaction rated by the reportant.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 12:43 pm]

In fact for complicated issues, civil servants responsible will call me back eg. HDB officer, LTA officer, Police IO - to request more detail information within the next few days.

And in most cases, issues are satisfactory resolved.

Civil servants chase me for details and proper closure rather than the other way round before OneService apps is launch - whereby I need to chase multiple agencies to get the issue resolved.

So using the appropriate tools is δΊ‹εŠεŠŸε€。Little work, good outcomes.

Rather than using the wrong tools (town council call) - δΊ‹ε€εŠŸεŠ。Alot of work, poor outcomes.


Andy, [13/1/2026 1:02 pm]

Whole intention of SSS is to literally to support elderly who needs support financially. Should the asset rich be eligible for such support, given that EA on average worth close to 1m? My opinion- no. 

Don't forget these SSS come from taxpayer money. Why should we fund the people who live in houses more expensive then ours πŸ˜‚

Khai Mun L., [13/1/2026 1:02 pm]

Promotion of oneservice app is not a cure-all though. There are folks that prefer taking to humans or are unfamiliar with tech.

Even cdc voucher allow manual

Khai Mun L., [13/1/2026 1:04 pm]

I recall during my short time at call centre for a town council, we had a centralized portal that can log cases to other agencies (only some though).

Perhaps the various town councils can work towards this direction. A common platform for council agents to log case, similar to our centralized healthcare system


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 1:05 pm]

1. Another critical issue is to look at ramping up sustainable domestic energy production - to safeguard any disruption to energy supply as geopolitical tensions hot up.

2. In case of war, water ways and flight path could be blocked and we will face difficulty in importing energy.

3. Hence ramping up domestic production of energy become important.

4. Solar energy, hydrogen gas, and SMR molten salt nuclear reactors - that could transform our domestic and import energy mix to safeguard our energy supply is critical - which currently 90% of our energy is imported.


Andy, [13/1/2026 1:09 pm]

Cross-Border Transport - honestly low impact to the general population. Suggest they don't waste time on this. Better to improve efficiency on buses/trains to/fro JB, quicker checkpoint clearing during peak etc


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 1:09 pm]

I agree for less tech savvy elderly OneService apps is a problem.

Agree that one centralise portal common platform call Centre for town council agents to log case is a good way for elderly.

But currently not available in many town council.

A few years ago, I go to the town council office to report an impending tree that is rotten at the trunk while I notice it during a brisk walk.

To my horror the town council officer (opposition one) say, it is not under the purview of town council and give me a telephone number to call npark. I get routed merry go round. Finally npark responded, couldn't find that tree.

Few months I discovered OneService apps. I took a photo, submitted a case (got GPS that pinpoint the tree location), npark go directly without fuss.

That's why you can see many frustrated residents as surface by some REACH participants here.

Even my neighbours who are unaware of OneService apps also raise similar frustration - whereby they need to jump from agencies to agencies to get their problem solved.

So can imagine the anger that spew from their mouth.


Andy, [13/1/2026 1:10 pm]

Was OneService discussed in parliament? πŸ€”


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 1:12 pm]

Today topic - any other issues that you want to surface.

Number item 8 - "Others" - "Please share your views in the chat below".


REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 2:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

RY, [13/1/2026 2:39 pm]

Totally agreed

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 2:40 pm]

Gov should organise Whatsapp block chat

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 2:40 pm]

Like my block do

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 2:41 pm]

Anything just say in Whatsapp and rc people will direct them to the correct channel

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 2:41 pm]

If not if someone see a snake in the middle of the road they don't know who to call

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 2:44 pm]

Even if rc people don't direct other residents also can help to submit report


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 2:53 pm]

My area got no such WhatsApp service.

Unless the MPs want to organise it.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 2:54 pm]

If I see a snake, I probably will call the police.


Kai Bin, [13/1/2026 3:07 pm]

They can call NParks hotline.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 3:08 pm]

Provided people know it is under npark purview.

Else it will get routed merry go round.


Kai Bin, [13/1/2026 3:08 pm]

I support the social media restrictions for minors.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 3:08 pm]

I didn't know it is under npark.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 3:09 pm]

They can also call acres


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 3:09 pm]

See so many agencies.

Don't know which one to call.


REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 3:37 pm]

Dear Contributors, 

In case you missed it, here are some updates from the parliamentary proceedings so far:

➡️ On food security targets under the revised "30 by 30" initiative: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/food-production-goals-fibre-protein-30-30-5854701

➡️ On National Council of Social Service (Amendment) Bill: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/new-membership-structure-for-national-council-of-social-service-among-proposed-changes-to-act⁠

➡️ On Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCS) assessing the diversity of offerings and consumer choice in heartland malls: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/competition-watchdog-ccs-will-step-in-if-consumer-welfare-is-compromised-low-yen-ling

➡️ On Local Qualifying Salary for S’porean workers: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/local-qualifying-salary-for-sporean-workers-to-be-refined-in-upcoming-budget-tan-see-leng

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 4:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 4:16 pm]

For cross boder it's not yet compatible with illegal service that bring you up to Thailand border


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:17 pm]

Based on SMS Parliamentary reply on why the food security target is revised from 30 X 30 to 20 X 35.

Pragmatism taking into account what Singapore can produce and scale locally - constraint by land spaces and market demand, it pose a challenge to achieve more domestic production.

I understand the constraints and can empathize with the need for revision downwards and extension of timeline.

Local farm producers cannot and will not produce more if Singaporeans and citizens don't buy the more expensive local production.

My only worries is don't know how the geopolitical tensions turn into that doesn't look good.

Numerous wars could break out looking at what is going on globally. It doesn't look good.

Hopefully, what we plan for is sufficient to ensure no disruption to our food supply even when numerous wars break out.


Or we should have contingency to suddenly ramp up our domestic food supplies such as :-

1. Green vegetables 

2. Egg production 

3. Fish farming 

4. Alternative meat such as plant based meat or cell culture tissue re-engineering meat 

From the word "Go" - to feed Singapore population when wars strike and import supply chain disrupted.

The looming crisis is out there manifesting - may not be too far from the truth.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:21 pm]

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/world/former-russian-president-medvedev-says-greenland-could-vote-join-russia-5854451

Senior Russian official says Greenland could vote to join Russia if Trump does not hurry to invade Greenland.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:22 pm]

Price and demand and going into supermarket and market is important


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:23 pm]

Understand.

That's why so difficult to ramp up our domestic food production.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:23 pm]

I go into the supermarket I not sure of those Leafly green produce from local


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:23 pm]

"No conversations' with US, says Cuban president after Trump threats.

Diaz-Canel responds on X to the US president's threats made on Sunday, saying that any relations "must be based on international law.""

Trump also want to bring down Cuba...

 https://www.channelnewsasia.com/world/cuba-president-us-trump-diaz-canel-havana-maduro-venezuela-5853721#:~:text=No%20conversations%27%20with,on%20international%20law.%22


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:24 pm]

During weekend my parents go to sungei tengah to buy vegetable from Koh fah

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:25 pm]

The thing is if logistic for a normal person to get local produce is so hard why would people go and get it


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:25 pm]

I just now visited NTUC fair price, I pick up one that looks like locally produce one without price tag.

When I go to the self checkout counter and scan the price, I almost fall off the chair.

It say $4.95.

I immediately cancel the order and look for another one - China brand $1.35...


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:28 pm]

Just too expensive. Wonder if high tech farming can bring down the price to similar range

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:28 pm]

If not Singapore will only have fish produce caught locally lor


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:28 pm]

I doubt so.

I also cannot get over the price differences psychologically even though I can afford it.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:30 pm]

Maybe from the start they should sell it to fine dining restaurant? Since those rich people can afford it

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:31 pm]

But then again high class restaurant do they serve Leafly green as much?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:33 pm]

That's what I suggested.

But look like not very helpful to boost the local farm produce demand .


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:34 pm]

I think our local farm produce probably should put beside the organic section lah at least people will recognize

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:34 pm]

Those tai tai will go and buy

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:36 pm]

Mark it as premium vegetables. Yah


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:36 pm]

Well hope local production food is successful.

Actually our lifeline hinge on it.

I am not so optimistic about what is happening globally.

It is manifesting.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:37 pm]

Ya heard from YouTube it's  war year for this 2 year

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:37 pm]

Red horse red sheep year


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:38 pm]

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/world/iran-protest-death-toll-more-500-rights-group-say-5851771

Trump says weighing tough response to Iran crackdown, Tehran says ready for war but also dialogue.

President Donald Trump said the US may meet Iranian officials and was in contact with the opposition, ⁠as he weighed a range of strong responses to the protests, including military options. 


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:39 pm]

Which chaos usually happens


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:40 pm]

"NATO says working on 'next steps' to boost Arctic security".

NATO EU could fight US if Trump bent on invading Greenland by force.

 https://www.channelnewsasia.com/world/nato-says-working-next-steps-boost-arctic-security-5853536#:~:text=NATO%20says%20working%20on%20%27next%20steps%27%20to%20boost%20Arctic%20security


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:40 pm]

It's 60 yr one cycle which means last time it happens is when she just gain independence


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:40 pm]

It mirror the replica of WW2 1930s.


Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:45 pm]

In 1966, the world saw escalating Vietnam War protests, the start of China's Cultural Revolution (https://www.google.com.sg/m?q=Cultural+Revolution&client=ms-opera-mobile&channel=new&espv=1&mstk=AUtExfA7N6l3EfLH0LIW2dh_0YJq_cscse_axaBBnCA9BFIMY9F7vyHG9W-Ivxq89sCbIf5ArXsIduraQMadcnEl32Z1CrPCgW8KZBoNbv2g_LOrOQha19Phd12lQJ9H_vitpmgMQlmm8dEqxIivLLYEaNZznrO6cdwaNPi6FJro9QOmO43sFR9KVqicttZhYHGCnfSfNbfzLIll0QON0EvKm_XGhATXSL8k7xMYuGiIBNLielxyXFZ-wRTU4tJ5ZMZV6JIhsm0S7BP7dx0NhO9AYTFV_pppc7JZaBRshoRHJylSuw&csui=3&ved=2ahUKEwif-tennYiSAxW4XWwGHY98L6oQgK4QegQIARAC), France's withdrawal from NATO's military command, and new nations gaining independence like Botswana and Lesotho. 

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:45 pm]

In 2016 we see us strikes on country and tension starting to form up

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:46 pm]

Ww3 will not come too soon at least still got 10 yr to come i think

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 5:46 pm]

Touch wood will not happen


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:47 pm]

Don't know.....


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 5:54 pm]

Unless China can control and refuse to strike Taiwan when the rest of the world go into turmoil.

Then we could be safe from world war at least in the Asia Pacific region.

But our investment elsewhere will be turned into dust even though physically we are safe.

That's why so important to dissuade China from being angry with Japan and Taiwan.

A wrong move, humanity could perish.

Hence PM Wong words though not popular is our life saviour.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [13/1/2026 6:00 pm]

See what happens in US - walk for peace.

Americans outpouring desire for peace is so strong.

https://babe118.blogspot.com/2026/01/walking-monks-for-peace-2000-miles-in.html


REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 6:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

G, [13/1/2026 6:02 pm]

Making life unnecessarily more expensive for everyone 

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/beverage-container-return-scheme-fees-drink-prices-importers-5854696

Daniel, [13/1/2026 6:05 pm]

Looking at the state of the recycling bin at my block and how it is not used correctly, I have to disagree and say that this seems to be the only way to make people dispose of their trash responsibly.

Daniel, [13/1/2026 6:06 pm]

A bit sad really

μ—¬μžμΉœκ΅¬, μ²«μ‚¬λž‘ πŸ†, [13/1/2026 6:11 pm]

I support this actually. Any way to slow the filling up of semakau by 2035 (?) is good. Also such drinks are unhealthy anyway.

Adam, [13/1/2026 6:31 pm]

For some weird reason, we still get served in disposable cups and plates in fast food like mcdonalds.

 For all the effort to move away from plastic straws, we still have plastic cutleries and many other stuff pushed by big food companies.

Why is all OUR FAULT

Always the hdb dweller fault for ruining the environment

Do we see big recycling bins at malls?

Why dont we get mcdonalds to wash their cups instead of giving us cups to throw away.

 Surely they can afford the extra space for cleaning facilities. Hawkers all over charge 20 cents for take away containers while washing their plates is free

G, [13/1/2026 6:32 pm]

How does charging more for drink cans encourage proper recycling bin use?

G, [13/1/2026 6:38 pm]

End of the day, why should the cost and effort of cleaning drink cans for recycling fall on the household?

The empty drink can has no value  to the household  when it's thrown. To recycle it properly, the household has to spend water to wash it and wait for it to dry.

The recycling company's raw materials (cans in the recycling bins) are basically free. They only pay transport costs to bring the cans to the recycling center.

G, [13/1/2026 6:40 pm]

"Prices of bottled and canned drinks in Singapore could rise by S$0.25 (US$0.20) to S$0.60 when a new national recycling programme kicks in from April"

But then

"Under the scheme, consumers will pay an additional 10 cents when buying most bottled and canned beverages ranging from 150ml to 3 litres."

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:50 pm]

Is there something we miss up if we paying 0.10 deposit why does it increase by 0.25

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:51 pm]

Where our 0.15 to 0.45 goes

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:53 pm]

Agree our fastfood restaurant chain gives disposable

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:53 pm]

Why no laws targeting at them

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:53 pm]

Why must it always be us the consumer

Daniel, [13/1/2026 6:55 pm]

I agree, fast food also.should be targeted.

G, [13/1/2026 6:57 pm]

So law say additional 10 cents..

But then what's gonna be reality? Additional 25 to 60 cents..

?????

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:58 pm]

Is pap called the price amplify party

Daniel, [13/1/2026 6:58 pm]

I think that's just the beverage companies using it as an opportunity to rise prices under the pretext of costs of relabelling. Seems excessive

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 6:59 pm]

Where the lightning break the coin into 2

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:00 pm]

Should have a law that say price shouldn't increase because of deposit if not will be fine

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:02 pm]

Other countries have the option to bring our own bottle to collect drinks

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:02 pm]

Maybe sg can implement it

365, [13/1/2026 7:03 pm]

Can try to create a repository to note current prices for beverages sold, then update them after the policy implements, fish out all the profiteering companies and shame them for it.

365, [13/1/2026 7:04 pm]

This idea I believe is implemented in Germany, seems quite normal there

365, [13/1/2026 7:04 pm]

But culture makes a huge difference in feasibility

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:04 pm]

Well can have hybrid system to test it out

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:04 pm]

If not consumer have no choice but to pay

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:06 pm]

That one 500ml coke bottle can reuse quite a few times

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:06 pm]

I think last time got glass bottle de

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:06 pm]

Can even reuse more

365, [13/1/2026 7:06 pm]

I'm still quite upset at the supermarket charging for plastic bags. If anything, it has encouraged me to take more free plastic bags whenever they are available so I can stockpile them to bag my rubbish

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:08 pm]

Btw are we allowed to buy large cartons of drinks from malaysia after this?

G, [13/1/2026 7:08 pm]

Unnecessary costs increases.

Will cost more for event caterings. Will cost more for festivities. Will cost more for PA events.

We will see more dumpster divers, dive to find cans to "return" for 10¢

365, [13/1/2026 7:08 pm]

With the alternatives, some are not designed to be easily tied up, so while in the past I always tie up my bagged rubbish before I dispose, now it's just good luck to whatever state and hope the rubbish doesn't spill

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:08 pm]

What if polis stop us and check every car for can drink

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:08 pm]

Won't lah

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:09 pm]

Just question what it is lor

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:09 pm]

If like that, ill just buy my drink from malaysia. Now really worth the effort

G, [13/1/2026 7:09 pm]

πŸ‘ in the end what happens? this drives people to buy plastic bags to bag trash.. encouraging more single use plastics.

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:09 pm]

I buy one one carton of energy drink from batam they just question me what it is lor

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Then nothing happens

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Say for cny

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

But really why they question

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Unless you are running a business and carrying a truckful

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Cause look like some mysterious liquid under xray

G, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Tell the truth lor. SG too expensive.. too much unnecessary costs

365, [13/1/2026 7:10 pm]

Buy from Malaysia just take note of gst limit if you buying with other items also

365, [13/1/2026 7:11 pm]

Or if you buying really a lot

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:11 pm]

One to 2 carton should last you for a week

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:11 pm]

Then you go in and get on weekends

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:11 pm]

I wonder if our ministers analysed the trash filling semakau. If we break it down how many percent from drink package.

How many percent from residential or commercial

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:12 pm]

And you earn the 0.10 deposit

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:12 pm]

Idea

365, [13/1/2026 7:12 pm]

I think there's some sort of scanning technology to detect the ones marked for recycling ones

365, [13/1/2026 7:12 pm]

Same thing in Germany

365, [13/1/2026 7:12 pm]

So other EU countries can't just bring over and take the 10c

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:13 pm]

But like that value dollar will tou first

Jun Ming, [13/1/2026 7:13 pm]

And Scarlett will be another onew

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:14 pm]

Im pretty sure we will see news of a scam syndicate making counterfeit tags to get money from recycling booths in a couple months

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:17 pm]

Speaking of malaysian drinks, will the recycle centers accept these unregistered cans without payout?

It will be kinda weird if they dont allow these perfectly fine cans to be recycled and instead we are forced to trash it. The irony

μ—¬μžμΉœκ΅¬, μ²«μ‚¬λž‘ πŸ†, [13/1/2026 7:42 pm]

I think dumpster diving is a good thing.

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:52 pm]

Nah the image is bad

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:52 pm]

And will probably mess up the place

Adam, [13/1/2026 7:53 pm]

If there is too much diver, gov will make hostile architecture. Just like how its hard to find benches that can lie down to fend off the pesky homeless

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 8:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 8:49 pm]

Dear Contributors,

⏰ We will be closing the chat in 10 minutes ⏰

Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan 😊

REACH Singapore, [13/1/2026 9:00 pm]

Dear Contributors

We will be closing the chat for today.

Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan 😊


====


Monday, January 12, 2026

REACH (Telegram) 112 -  What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

(SK)

12 Jan 2026 (10am - 7pm)


REACH (Telegram)

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 9:45 am]

Dear Contributors,

Welcome Back! 😊

⏰ We will be opening the chat from 10am to 9pm today. ⏰

House Rules (short version of our Terms of Use) to keep in mind:

1. Be kind and respectful. We all want to be in a safe space to share our views. 

2. Any and all threatening, abusive, vulgar or racially, religiously and ethnically objectionable content is prohibited. 

3. Consider the quiet ones among us and give them a chance to comment. 

4. No need to repeat your comment or in different forms (including caps) - we heard you loud and clear the first time. 

5. Let's protect each other's privacy and keep contact details in this group what it should always be - confidential. 

Full set of Terms of Use: https://www.reach.gov.sg/Participate/reach-telegram-group/REACH-Telegram-Group-Chat-Terms-of-Use/

We will strive to uphold these rules to ensure this is a safe space for all. 

Please be assured that the points made by participants during the chat are aggregated and shared with relevant agencies. 

The topic will be posted shortly. 

Thank you. 

Megan 😊

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 10:01 am]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

Parliament will sit today (12 Jan) at 12.00pm. Parliamentary questions will cover the performance of investment vehicles Temasek & GIC, the changes to the Integrated Shield Plan and funding for athletes. Four new bills will also be introduced, including the Health Information Bill, which will help streamline patients' medical records.

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

πŸ“Œ Performance of GIC & Temasek

Ten MPs filed questions regarding the performance of investment vehicles Temasek & GIC. 

Temasek, the Government’s investment company, and GIC, Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund, manage the country’s reserves. 

However, a Financial Times article published in December 2025 had questioned the performance of the two investment entities, saying that their recent returns have “compared unfavourably with many global peers”.

Questions were filed on whether the Government was satisfied with the performance of GIC & Temasek and about the metrics used to assess the performance of GIC & Temasek. Questions were also asked if the two entities will still be able to provide a steady stream of contributions to the Government’s Budget amid a more volatile investment landscape.

πŸ“Œ Integrated Shield Plan (IP) Riders

The Ministry of Health (MOH) announced in November that Integrated Shield Plan policyholders who buy new riders from next April will no longer be allowed to cover the minimum deductibles. A rider is an optional add-on that provides extra coverage beyond the main policy, paid fully in cash. 

MPs asked questions about specific indicators of sustainability in private health insurance premiums and how families will be supported if these payments become unaffordable.

πŸ“Œ Funding for athletes

Funding for athletes is another topic the House will discuss, coming on the back of the recent SEA Games in Thailand, which sparked discussion on whether there was enough support for Singapore’s sportsmen and sportswomen.

Six questions were raised about funding for Singaporean athletes. Among the questions tabled is whether the Major Games Award Programme, which provides monetary awards for SEA Games gold medallists, among others, can also include SEA Games silver and bronze medallists. 

πŸ“Œ Bills to be debated in Parliament

Parliament will also debate four Bills.

These include the Public Sector (Governance) (Amendment) Bill and Health Information Bill, the National Council of Social Service (Amendment) Bill and the Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill.

Of note, the Health Information Bill will require all licensed healthcare providers, including private clinics, clinical laboratories and radiological services, inclusive of retail pharmacy licensees to contribute selected health information to the National Electronic Health Record (NEHR). This move ensures that important health information for patient care is accessible to providers across the healthcare landscape, thereby enhancing quality and continuity of care for patients.

πŸ“Œ Other Issues

Other parliamentary questions include questions about fire safety in light of the tragic high-rise fire in Tai Po (Hong Kong), the changes to Singapore "30 x 30" sustainability targets and efforts to combat money laundering.

πŸ‘‰πŸ»   https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/gic-and-temaseks-performance-ip-rider-changes-on-the-agenda-when-parliament-sits-on-jan-12 

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.parliament.gov.sg/parliamentary-business/order-paper

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/integrated-shield-plan-rider-co-payment-cap-deductibles-medisave-covered-5489971?cid=internal_sharetool_web_12012026_cna

πŸ‘‰πŸ» https://www.moh.gov.sg/others/health-regulation/health-information-protection/

πŸ‘‰πŸ»https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/new-law-proposed-to-mandate-sharing-patients-info-among-healthcare-providers

πŸ‘‰πŸ»https://www.straitstimes.com/tech/proposed-law-changes-in-spore-to-cut-red-tape-in-data-sharing-speed-up-social-support-experts?ref=latest

πŸ‘‰πŸ»https://www.channelnewsasia.

----


REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 10:30 am]

Dear Contributors, 

Pls note that the last link on the topic is as follows:

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/singapore-sports-council-bill-mccy-mind-sports-esports-5443961

Thank you. 

Megan

365, [12/1/2026 10:30 am]

Investment performances always have ups and downs, I would think GIC and Temasek has to take a more conservative investment approach compared to other private investment entities, so a lower investment return compared to them isn't surprising. They can't just all-in S&P500 then hope for the best like many retail investors boasting high returns from doing exactly that. 

In the same way, when there's market downturn, they lose less than the private entities. From what I'm able to search, the only year they've taken a net loss is during the financial crisis of 2008.

Different market environment and conditions favor different investment strategy, and no one can miraculously pivot their strategies to exactly the ideal one everytime.

So far they still seem to be doing ok for long term at 5.7% annualized for 20 years, and 3.8% after adjusting for global inflation.

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 11:00 am]

[ Poll : Which issue(s) are you most interested in for today's Parliament sitting? Share your reasons in the chat! (You may choose more than one option.) ]

- Performance of GIC and Temasek

- Integrated Shield Plan (IP) riders

- Funding for Athletes

- Fire safety measures 

- Changes to Singapore’s sustainability targets

- The Health Information Bill

- The Singapore Sports Council (Amendment) Bill

- Others (please share your views in the chats below)

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 11:02 am]

Dear Contributors,

Please take a moment to participate in our polls and share your opinion. The poll questions are pinned for easy reference! You can choose more than one option and your vote is anonymous. 

We look forward to hearing your thoughts on today’s topic!

πŸ’¬ What are your thoughts on the issues to be discussed in Parliament today? Which issue interests you the most?

Thank you.

Megan

Kai Bin, [12/1/2026 11:05 am]

I voted for fire safety measures, especially after the tragic incident that occurred in Hong Kong last year.

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 12:00 pm]

Dear contributors,

Parliament sitting is now live.

Catch the livestream of today's Parliament sitting here: 

https://www.youtube.com/live/wVGcrDpDt_4?si=aOjpCCFpwsW7u-1B

RY, [12/1/2026 12:40 pm]

With the revision of the Medishield IP, many are expected and may downgrade policy, and switch to public hospitals going forward

Hope MOH may expand SG public healthcare svs, since there maybe influx into public hospitals, and longer waiting time are expected for subsidised patients

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 2:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 2:02 pm]

Dear Contributors, 

Pls note that the last link on the topic is as follows:

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/singapore-sports-council-bill-mccy-mind-sports-esports-5443961

Thank you. 

Megan


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 2:12 pm]

400. I post in REACH (Telegram)  LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [14/10/2025 12:24 pm]:-

6. As for outdoor open court picket balls, it is really very noisy - and could disturb the residents even during day time.

7. Wonder why not make picket ball court indoor - in CC like badminton court convertible into picket ball court - whoever book first.

8. Another recommendation is that, can picket bats be transformed into cushion or rubber material that will absorb noise rather than plain wood that produce a very sharp "piak piak" sounds that are very loud and irritable.

9. Can the picket ball be transformed into rubber material that can absorb noise rather than the plastic type like table tennis ball producing high pitch "piak piak sounds".

10. A simple change in design of the picket bats and balls - can go a long way to solve the ongoing irritant and conflict within the neighborhood.

----

Straits Times Published Jan 11, 2026, 03:53 PM Updated Jan 11, 2026, 08:34 PM

'Silent pickleball’: Mountbatten residents trial playing with foam balls to reduce noise.

“The general consensus is that there is no issue with playing pickleball at the neighourhood courts, but the issue is the very sharp ‘pop’ sound that’s being generated,” said Ms Gho, of when plastic balls strike hard paddles and ricochet off the floor.

“Understandably, some residents may feel uncomfortable that their daily routines are disrupted

Complaints about noisy pickleball games have surfaced periodically on social media, as a source of tension among some residents. by the noise.”

Mountbatten residents are trying "silent pickleball" using foam balls to reduce noise generated by the game.

MP Gho Sze Kee aims to minimise disputes with considerate play and a "give-and-take approach", and will hold a silent pickleball tournament in the coming months.

Foam balls reduce noise to conversation levels, and residents said they support their use for quieter gameplay and less neighbourhood disturbance.

“If we can minimise it, that’ll be a great win-win situation.”


RY, [12/1/2026 2:35 pm]

Ms Eileen Chong, a Non-Constituency Member of Parliament (NCMP) whom spoke at Parliament just now, she has bring up many good points abt sharing of personal data and cybersecurity vs worldwide scamming


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:13 pm]

GIC and Temasek Holdings Performance


1. It is reported by Financial Times that both GIC and Temasek Holdings average annual return over 10 years about over 5% in nominal US terms - the weakest among 50 Global Peers evaluated by Global SWF.

While Canada funds achieve stronger returns 9.2% and 7.4% respectively.


2. I will like to say that 7.4% to 9.2% annualised return for a 10 years fund are very good performance. 

But based on my knowledge, many private funds cannot achieve such high returns. In fact worldwide Insurance participating funds can only promise 3.25% to 4.25% annualised return for 10 years or longer like 15 years, 20 years.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:17 pm]

3. Hence, GIC and Temasek Holdings above 5% annualised annual return average over 10 years - seems to be quite respectable compared to the private Insurance Participating funds of 3.25% to 4.25% annualised return.


4. But having say so, if GIC and Temasek Holdings if benchmarked against 50 Global Peers evaluated by Global SWF - both our Sovereign Funds seem to have underperformed.


RY, [12/1/2026 3:22 pm]

Mr Henry Kwek (Kebun Baru Single Member Constituency).  also bring up quite many good points abt data sharing for PSGA


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:23 pm]

5. But on hindsight, scanning the investment climate across the World, there are higher and higher financial risks among traditional safe and conservative financial tools eg.

a. US Treasury Bonds - which are traditionally safe, guaranteed by Fed, repectable interest rate return - but getting increasingly risky as many government dump the bonds while private hedge funds are taking over demanding higher interest rate, making debt load of US Treasury higher and higher and default risk higher and higher at the backdrop of US$38 trillion debt and still rising.


b. China Big Tech, property investment are also risky - and many financial investors, banks got burned.


c. Also under the background of geopolitical tussling, investment climate is becoming less cosy.


Though where there is crisis, there will be opportunities. 

The crux is where to find and pinpoint the opportunities to ensure a safe and reliable income return.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:32 pm]

6. Having say so, I will like to venture a suggestion :

Now both our Sovereign Funds are mainly θ‡ͺεŠ› (that is we are employing local and foreign financial talents to do investment - under a very stringent sets of rules, guidelines and processes - to ensure our investment are safe and not indulge in too risky investment --- which is a respectable approach) - to safeguard our hard-earned Sovereign Wealth and our CPF while earning returns for our NIRC and grow our wealth.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:38 pm]

But having say so, as benchmark with global peers, we seems to be too conservative.

Hence I will like to suggest, how about both Sovereign Funds set aside 10% and adopt the approach of ε€ŸεŠ› - δ»–εŠ›。

That is, setting aside 10% - for GIC (I guess 10% of $1 trillion - $100 billion), for Temasek Holdings ($434 billion - $43.4 billion) - to appoint a few (to spread our risks) respectable, safe and reliable Global or Local Funds that has higher financial performance - to help both our Sovereign Funds invest.

Let see they can help both our Sovereign Funds ramp up our annualised returns to 6% or higher?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:43 pm]

Note:- As both of our Sovereign Funds are safeguarding our National Wealth and our CPF while earning respectable income returns - we should cap the approach of ε€ŸεŠ› - δ»–εŠ› to 10% and not higher, while the rest of 90% will still adopt the GIC and Temasek Holdings conservative approach of investment.


Hanny, [12/1/2026 3:49 pm]

I am really pissed with the way town council works


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:49 pm]

Can please elaborate.


Hanny, [12/1/2026 3:49 pm]

No mood


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:50 pm]

Hahaha.

No elaboration can't solve problems.


Hanny, [12/1/2026 3:50 pm]

Time for town council to be transparent with its process and procedures

Hanny, [12/1/2026 3:51 pm]

I don’t expect this group to solve my problem. Just venting my anger.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 3:52 pm]

Town council mainly to rectify problems or faults around our living areas.

Not difficult problem to resolve.


REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 4:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:02 pm]

Normally I submit any issues or problems via "OneService" Apps.

Issues will be logged and process flow will follow.

Acknowledgement usually within 1 day.

Depending on the complexity of the issues or problems - it take 3 to 5 days to resolve.

Most issues 95% I submitted via "OneService" Apps are resolved.

Except difficult issues like wrong demarcation of cycling path and pedestrian path - I thought won't be resolved, but few months later, I discovered it was rectified.

National issues like booking driving lessons with the driving centres - still yet to resolve.

Other than that, most issues I submitted via "OneService" Apps are properly resolved and closed.

You can rate their service satisfaction in "OneService" Apps after completion.


G, [12/1/2026 4:10 pm]

"Reasonable and within expectations"

Have expectations been set so low? It's doing worse than index funds

Why is it acceptable to accept such low expectations?

"https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/singapore/returns-generated-gic-temasek-reasonable-and-within-expectations-jeffrey-siow"

G, [12/1/2026 4:16 pm]

Performance of SWF has a direct impact on available money for govt budget. If they don't perform well, won't that mean we will be taxed more to fund more and more gov spending?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:16 pm]

Speaking in Parliament on Monday (Jan 12), he noted that GIC has achieved a real return of 3.8 per cent per annum over the past 20 years, while Temasek has reported a total shareholder return of 8 per cent per annum in US dollar terms over the last 20-year period.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:18 pm]

Temasek Holdings achieve a 8% annual return for 20 years is a very good performance - for a $434 billion funds.

Better than many private funds notably Insurance Participating Funds that can achieve 3.25% to 4.25%.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:21 pm]

Bearing in mind that Temasek Holdings do take risks in their investment - such as FTX, Indonesia fish farming - that we achieve total loss.

High return do come with high risk.

Hence Temasek Holdings achieving 8% return for 20 years fund is very respectable.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:23 pm]

Having say so, GIC are holding, accumulating and growing our CPF and national wealth - will need to be conservative.

And cannot afford to take too risky investment.

I think I support Minister Jeffrey Seow explanation the need for GIC to continue with the conservative approach of investment.


REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 4:25 pm]

Dear Contributors, 

In case you missed it, here are some updates from the parliamentary proceedings so far:

➡️ On the Integrated Shield plan rider changes: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/politics/surge-capacity-may-be-implemented-if-more-turn-to-public-hospitals-following-ip-rider-changes-moh

➡️ On the new active mobility-related bill introduced in Parliament:

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/pma-medical-certificate-erp-2-obu-parliament-5852346

➡️ On investment returns generated by GIC and Temasek: https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/singapore/returns-generated-gic-temasek-reasonable-and-within-expectations-jeffrey-siow

G, [12/1/2026 4:25 pm]

Why compare with private funds and not other SWFs?

https://www.ft.com/content/2171fbb4-b8e3-413d-8f31-98ec909fd74a


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:25 pm]

I will also like the Government to consider setting aside 10% of both Sovereign Funds to allocate to trusted, safe, reliable global or local funds that have been performing well to help to further boost our earnings.


G, [12/1/2026 4:26 pm]

Even so, GIC have underperformed against GIC's own reference portfolio

G, [12/1/2026 4:29 pm]

So gambling away SWF and then reporting 8% is "respectable"?

Temasek lost S$375mil on FTX.. That's basically the cost of the vanity founders memorial project


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:31 pm]

Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPP) and Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan reported stronger returns of 9.2% and 7.4% respectively.

Hence Temasek Holdings achieving 8% against Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan of 7.4% is a good performance though slightly lower than 9.2% of CPP.

But like what I say earlier, higher return come with higher risk.

As long as Temasek Holdings is able to perform in such level consistently, I think is a good result.


G, [12/1/2026 4:36 pm]

Not sure where the 8% came from. 

"According to Global SWF, Temasek and GIC averaged only 5% annual returns in US dollar terms over the past decade — well below their peers like the Canada Pension Plan (9.2%) and Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (7.4%). "

https://glosema.group/news/are-singapores-investment-giants-falling-behind-global-peers/


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:37 pm]

Read the business time Parliamentary speech by Minister Jeffrey Seow which you attached.


G, [12/1/2026 4:37 pm]

Jeffrey claim 8%

Global SWF say 5%

Someone not telling the truth


365, [12/1/2026 4:39 pm]

Past decade vs past 20 year, different lengths of time


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:41 pm]

I think swf average out GIC and Temasek Holdings.


G, [12/1/2026 4:41 pm]

This number is from the last decade

G, [12/1/2026 4:42 pm]

But this number is from last 2 decades

G, [12/1/2026 4:42 pm]

So need to compare within same time frames right?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:42 pm]

Though I agree longer duration usually bring higher returns.


G, [12/1/2026 4:42 pm]

Should not compare 8% over 20 years with 7.4% over 10 years

G, [12/1/2026 4:44 pm]

You misled by comparing returns over 20 years vs returns over 10 years, then use the 20 years returns to claim "good performance"


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:44 pm]

As when both Sovereign Funds are setup, their financial investment is always invested 20 years as their approach.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:46 pm]

But as both of our sovereign funds have overlapping funds maturing, annually, the realised return, nirc we received and can spend from income realised by Temasek is indeed 8%.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:50 pm]

That's swf investment strategy target 10 years investment returns but taking higher investment risk.

Our sovereign funds use 20 years return at lower risk but still generate good returns annually.

I feel more comfortable with both our sovereign funds approach of 20 years investment horizons as compared to swf 10 years horizons especially in this more turbulence geopolitical climate.

Taking lower risk than higher risk will ensure our capital and wealth are safeguarded.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:53 pm]

Having say so, I will urge the government to consider my suggestion to set aside 10% for both Sovereign Funds to engage trusted well performing funds management to further boost our earnings.

I support our government explanation and approach of both Sovereign Funds current investment approach - that will ensure our sovereign wealth and CPF are more safely invested.


G, [12/1/2026 4:53 pm]

Comment doesn't make sense.

Comparisons above vs other SWF are historical, not future projections / risk appetite

Fact is, over the last 10 years, GIC and temasek have underperformed quite badly vs other SWF

365, [12/1/2026 4:55 pm]

Investment opportunities might be another factor, I would expect both to have their individual access to private investments not available for other investors. 

In terms of scale, Canada has more advantages, coupled with their natural resources that some of their organizations can profit off of. 

Glosema group article also points out that GIC has a more conservative approach, "lower in risk and rich in diversification". This naturally trends to lower performance than the peers, especially since the last 5 years have seen some huge recovery and boom in equities growth post covid, which favors profiles with a riskier appetite. 

Compared to their 20 year timeline, 2008 is almost 20 years ago, though not quite yet. After 2008, it's been unprecedented continuous growth until covid hit in 2020, so most of the growth is definitely weighted between these 12 years.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:55 pm]

I have a chance to learn from a very strong mathematician.

He use statistics, with graph and charts to show historical trends - and indeed proven that our 20 years investment horizons is a proven investment model for safe and trusted investment.

Consistently deliver the promised returns year in and year out.

He told me this is math - empirically reliable and always proven - that can ride over few swan events like COVID, financial crisis.


365, [12/1/2026 4:57 pm]

If there's any statistics for other funds to compare their 20 year to 10 year annualized returns, I would be interested. Post 2008 recovery had a long bull run. I would expect most funds to have their 20 year to beat their 10 year.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 4:58 pm]

Yes, going with math model, both our sovereign funds is almost sound averaging out 20 years instead of 10 years.


365, [12/1/2026 4:58 pm]

There's multiple differentiator and reasons, but private investment opportunities I think has to be one of the bigger ones

365, [12/1/2026 4:59 pm]

If we take the US for example, their military industrials is raking in big for them, I doubt other nations can invest in it

G, [12/1/2026 5:01 pm]

Difficult to find readily available public stats for 20 yr SWF historical performance. 

So when Jeffrey threw out that 8% over 20 year stat, it's just a standalone stat with little significance when it cannot be compared. 

It's like saying so-and-so is xyz cm tall.. so what?

G, [12/1/2026 5:03 pm]

Regardless, SG's SWF needs to perform a lot better since their returns significantly fund govt spending.. If they continue to perform at current low levels, then won't it be safe to say that taxes need to be raised to continue the current trend of increasing govt spending?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:03 pm]

I also have opportunities to speak to a few very experienced fund managers.

They say the averaging funds if pitch at 20 years can almost guarantee the return promise if the investment portfolios are very well diversified - because money if don't fall on one portfolio will go to other portfolios.

So both our sovereign funds approach of 20 years plus GIC well diversified investment though at a lower return compared to Temasek more targeted investment at high growth areas - will certainly make our investment risk lower.

Hence I am very comfortable with our Minister explanation and both our sovereign funds approach in investment.

One defend, one attack.


365, [12/1/2026 5:04 pm]

8% is to show that we are still safe long term wise, we still have buffer.

I never follow what was spoken and referenced in parliament, but GIC website shows return over 20 years ending 31 Mar 2025, denominated in USD to be 5.7%

365, [12/1/2026 5:04 pm]

Not sure if the 8% is after conversion, or if it's a couple months ahead adjusted for

G, [12/1/2026 5:05 pm]

jeffrey say 8% is temasek

LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:05 pm]

Yes.

Math model don't lies.

Also actual return don't lie.


G, [12/1/2026 5:06 pm]

Yes, govt spending also don't lie. Money need to come from somewhere. 

If SWF continue to underperform, and govt want to continue increasing spending, then how?

Need to raise taxes right?

G, [12/1/2026 5:08 pm]

https://www.mof.gov.sg/policies/reserves/net-investment-returns-contribution/


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:10 pm]

1. A good thing is our sovereign wealth is compounded.

2. That's every year, as we earn income, half is allocated to nirc to spend, half put back as capital.

3. That means, our sovereign capital become bigger and can be invested to earn higher return, in which our nirc also become bigger every year to fund our higher government spendings annually.


G, [12/1/2026 5:12 pm]

So that also means when the actual income earned is lowered, and govt still wants to increase spending, then taxes need to be raised to fund the increased govt spending right?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:12 pm]

4. Higher return means our nirc will grow bigger to fund higher taxes.

5. I feel comfortable with our government and sovereign funds approach to grow our wealth.

6. Slow and steady win the race.

Greed sometimes will burn our capital not to mention higher return.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:14 pm]

7. Having say so, I propose government do a fine tune to the current approach - ie. Set aside 10% of both Sovereign Funds to appoint few reliable high performing funds management to spread the risk to earn a bit more - hopefully boost our annual earnings to 6 % - our medium target.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:21 pm]

Btw I was briefed by some experience fund managers that given the current more challenging geopolitical environment, 10 years investment horizons is actually a higher financial risk - may not be a sufficient timeline to move investment funds around the various financial portfolio to reap higher returns and run away from more dangerous investment tools.

They told me 15 years to 20 years is a better timeline to earn almost guaranteed higher and safer investment returns.

I think our Minister explanation and both our sovereign funds 20 investment horizon is a math proven, sound and reliable approach.


G, [12/1/2026 5:25 pm]

Isn't this conflating projection vs historical returns?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:27 pm]

As both our sovereign funds have overlapping and mature funds every year - indeed it is a true realised return.


G, [12/1/2026 5:27 pm]

How does current more challenging geopolitical environment affect what happened 10 or 20 years ago?

That's like saying things happening today has the ability to change what happened in the past


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:28 pm]

Read global financial news.

Study economics.

Be conversant with statistics.

And prove the theory through hands on investment.

If not listen to experience funds manager explanation.

And look at empirical results.


G, [12/1/2026 5:29 pm]

So are you saying a 20 year projection or 20 year look back into history?


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:31 pm]

Btw, any bank RM in this forum?

I think you can explain better.


G, [12/1/2026 5:32 pm]

You use "horizon". Do you mean looking into the future or looking back into the past?

This kind don't need RM to explain

G, [12/1/2026 5:35 pm]

If "horizon" you mean looking into the future, then how does that relate to 10 / 20 year historical performances of SWFs?

If by "horizon" you mean looking back into the past, then how does "the current more challenging geopolitical environment" affect events in the past?

G, [12/1/2026 5:36 pm]

You don't make any sense at all


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:36 pm]

I think 365 got a good grasp of what I mean.


G, [12/1/2026 5:36 pm]

365 comments are understandable and makes sense. Yours does not

G, [12/1/2026 5:43 pm]

If this govt wants to spend more and more money, then they better make sure their revenue generators perform better. 

Don't hide behind comments like "bottom-up investor" and then ask Singaporeans to accept the low historical returns.  

Because we know, if the govt didn't earn enough through and the NIRC cannot adequately support their spending, then they will take money from Singaporeans through taxes to fund their budget

Higher taxes just results in artificially increased costs of living


365, [12/1/2026 5:51 pm]

Generally a longer time period captures more ups and downs that a profile will experience compared to a shorter time period. It demonstrates the resilience of an investment profile. A shorter time period demonstrates how well it is performing in the current environment.

If we were to compare it as a standalone, is that the strategy is resilient but not as well suited for the current environment, might be slow to pivot. I honestly would expect this because there's only so much risk they can afford to take, they would rather take the win less than lose more choice.

If we can compare across funds to see if there's any general patterns between the funds, then we can attribute it to the financial environment changes (such as all markets down during 2008 financial crisis and covid).

I'm more curious on how the 20 year MA has trended to account for the overall resilience. We will expect this number to go up in 2029 since it will exclude the poor performance of 2008 by then.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:52 pm]

Good explanation.

You in financial field?


365, [12/1/2026 5:53 pm]

As to whether this is sustainable for budget, I really can't tell without the numbers to crunch. Just because they could use 50% of the expected long-term real returns in the past, doesn't mean they have been using the full 50%.


365, [12/1/2026 5:54 pm]

Just studied it in poly, but never delved into the field, so at most just a learned layman


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:54 pm]

Oh I also layman.

Did some study in Uni.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 5:58 pm]

But I do see a few real cases.

1. 10 years financial horizon - the investment return + and minus the targeted earnings. Not very accurate as the investment timeline too short.

2. 15 years horizons - almost always exceeded the targeted earnings.

3. 20 years horizons - the intermediate locked earnings achieved - almost will be able to well exceed the targeted earnings.

That's why I very confident the Minister Parliament statement is true and both Sovereign Funds investment approaches are on the right track.


REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 6:00 pm]

πŸ“’ Topic πŸ“’

365, [12/1/2026 6:11 pm]

As much as I want to, I can't think of a good direct benchmark from public data. At best is to compare trend lines between the funds and not their actual returns, due to too many other factors in play. Comparison between multiple trend lines tell a better story on performance, if majority trend upwards and we are the only 1 or part of a few trending downwards, then it's alarm bells. 

Private investment opportunities like I previously mentioned, currency strength, available reserves leading to different risk appetites, and even their geopolitical standing. 

What's the worse for US if they take a loss? Print more money, hand out more bonds, and take the entire world with them through inflation. Much different consequences than if our own funds were to take a loss. 

We do have losses such as FTX, but it's the nature that there are gains and losses through all investment strategies. Could be a small portion being allocated to these exploratory opportunities, as long as it doesn't tank the entire fund, I find it to be normal. The problem lies again in not knowing the numbers, a couple hundred million loss does seem huge to us, but how much is it in terms of percentage of overall assets?

If I have the data, my own benchmark would be how much for the 50% are we utilizing, and has that been increasing, decreasing or remaining stable? Granted there is good reason that the total AUM is not public information, I think it should be safe to at least reassure Singaporeans by giving us the utilization rate, or at least into allocation tiers.

G, [12/1/2026 6:33 pm]

HDB flats are not soldier barracks leh

"MP Ng Chee Meng (PAP-Jalan Kayu) noted that there were three serious fires that resulted in deaths in 2025. 

He suggested conducting fire drills at public housing estates so residents get "more hands-on education besides head knowledge"."

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/review-early-findings-hong-kong-investigation-wang-fuk-court-fire-5852651

Caleb, [12/1/2026 6:36 pm]

no need spam. Can just pin this msg will do.

G, [12/1/2026 6:38 pm]

"Questions were filed on whether the government was satisfied with the performance of GIC & Temasek..."

When the board of directors in GIC are

Chairman: 

Lee Hsien Loong

Deputy Chairman: 

Lawrence Wong

Directors:

Gan Kim Yong

Heng Swee Keat

Lim Hng Kiang

...

https://www.gic.com.sg/who-we-are/board-of-directors/

Khai Mun L., [12/1/2026 8:14 pm]

I don't bother with the financial performance during these 'boom' times.

Why these critics never complain why we not follow the average market losses during the downturns. Instead, sg made profits


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 8:16 pm]

Hmm ..

That's a good observation.

Averaging out the returns will give us sustainable and consistent income annually.

Whereas a year return to measure and conclude our sovereign funds not doing well this year while other funds are doing well is not a good comparison.


Khai Mun L., [12/1/2026 8:19 pm]

And our sovereign funds are not actually 'not doing well', they are still making profits.

It's like I won 3rd prize in 4d, but still complain i underperforming because i didn't get the top prize


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 8:22 pm]

Yes.

In fact I like both our sovereign funds approach in investment and safeguarding our wealth and CPF.

It is time tested and proven.

I also use similar model to invest my passive income.

One defend, one attack.

For decades, the income return is respectable and consistent though I don't do as well as GIC and Temasek percentage return.

But still respectable and safe.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 8:28 pm]

θ·―ι₯ηŸ₯ι©¬εŠ›。

Long distance runner see the real potential of the horse stamina.

A short sprint though very fast can win in short term - but cannot last.


LCL (Danny εΏƒ), [12/1/2026 8:29 pm]

We are running a marathon, not a sprint.


REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 8:52 pm]

Dear Contributors,

⏰ We will be closing the chat in 10 minutes ⏰

Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan 😊

365, [12/1/2026 8:59 pm]

Yeah agreed on this, they obviously have to manage the risk, and lower risk is naturally lower returns, but also lose less in a downturn. Since this is tied to budget, the better metrics will be the utilization rate, if it's near the 50% cap consistently then it's a cause for concern.

REACH Singapore, [12/1/2026 9:04 pm]

Dear Contributors

We will be closing the chat for today.

Thank you very much for being part of our Telegram chat and participating actively.

Goodnight!

Megan 😊


====